according to this site: Walker #1 Olsen #38 Tomlinson #41 Bush #46 + Detmer #43.

May 24, 2016
2:23:57pm

robin 3rd String

http://www.rantsports.com/ncaa-football/2015/11/07/ranking-the-50-greatest-college-football-players-of-all-time/

You'd think McMahon and Young would be close to being on this list. Also surprising that Faulk not on this list. Maybe he was better in NFL than in college.

Report problem with this ad

robin

Bio page: robin
Joined: Apr 21, 2002
Last login: May 23, 2024
Total posts: 4,294 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Best Player BYU Football ever faced? Marshall Faulk? Whos on that list?

buckeyecougarguy

5/24/16 10:25am

Dalton, Hughes, A. Smith, kickoff return dude from Hawaii

BlackBart

5/24/16 10:28am

Dalton was the first name that came to my mind

chazen

5/24/16 1:26pm

Thomas Jones at LES was pretty impressive

BYUheaven

5/24/16 10:28am

At the time? Maybe Russell Maryland.

byubyu

5/24/16 10:28am

Sam Bradford could be on the list.

beebs4lyfe

5/24/16 10:29am

I totally forgot Marshawn Lynch and Desean Jackson.

beebs4lyfe

5/24/16 10:31am

DeSean Jackson did bad things to our defense.

Mayor of Cougartown

5/24/16 10:53am

I agree with Faulk. Most amazing college back I've seen in person. He was a man

specsauce

5/24/16 10:30am

Reggie Bush was a freak show in college.

RichieRich

5/24/16 10:30am

That USC team was amazing. That season had two great home games in the preseason

blackandblue

5/24/16 10:41am

the correct answer is Reggie Bush...

BigYfan

5/24/16 11:07am

Oregon State QB that won the Heisman in the 60s

Y05

5/24/16 11:51am

meant for OP

Y05

5/24/16 11:52am

Dickerson, Faulk, Jonathan Ogden (who almost single-handedly won the game) are 3

BigD Coug

5/24/16 10:33am

James had a better game than Dickerson though. I guess the distinction would

BYUheaven

5/24/16 10:36am

Both Dickerson and James weren't superstars yet in 1980

donnerstag

5/24/16 10:44am

James had more yards...

CoachSpeak

5/24/16 1:45pm

I wouldn't vote James for anything except javelin catcher on the track team.

CougarThug

5/24/16 7:09pm

Eric Bieniemy from Colorado was pretty good in '88

BYUBandfan

5/24/16 10:37am

Tough to answer because there have been so many great players but Gerald McCoy

The Dude Abides

5/24/16 10:39am

Jim McMahon in practice

maizecoug

5/24/16 10:39am

Of those not already mentioned, Demarco Murray held to 58 yards rushing in 2009

Thrill

5/24/16 10:41am

Was Freeney on SU when they visited LES?

Crush4

5/24/16 10:43am

IDK, but David Tyree was, IIRC.

Y05

5/24/16 12:20pm

Tyree & Freeney both played.

BigD Coug

5/24/16 12:33pm

Justin Tuck.

Crush4

5/24/16 10:44am

Herschel Walker

golf1

5/24/16 10:46am

I went to that game.

SoCalCoug

5/24/16 1:46pm

They played against Brian Urlacher... He was a stud in college

RaggaeCoug

5/24/16 10:47am

Al Noga did whatever he wanted to against BYU

donnerstag

5/24/16 10:48am

Jerry Hughes

Crush4

5/24/16 10:49am

Steve Smith

Mayor of Cougartown

5/24/16 10:51am

I was happy to send him out on a loss.

Crush4

5/24/16 10:52am

Marshawn Lynch and Reggie Bush come to mind.

Josef K

5/24/16 10:54am

Faulk, Tomlinson, Lynch, Bush and Walker are some of the

kimdaddy35

5/24/16 10:55am

Oops, meant to add Dickerson to that list as well.

kimdaddy35

5/24/16 10:56am

Dickerson and Craig James both killed us ... fortunately McMahon was better

ManicBlue

5/24/16 11:00am

In our favor McMahon, Detmer and one year of Young were about the greatest

kimdaddy35

5/24/16 11:06am

Craig James also killed a bunch of hookers, IIRC

Jericho

5/24/16 11:12am

according to Mike Leach it was 5

Wear Blue

5/25/16 9:36pm

It helped that SMU let up, because they thought they had won

donnerstag

5/24/16 11:15am

they played 56 minutes

Y05

5/24/16 12:07pm

My point stands that if they had played 60 minutes

donnerstag

5/24/16 12:39pm

I should probably include the Bus in that list as well

kimdaddy35

5/24/16 11:57am

Jerome Bettis, another HOF back

Y05

5/24/16 12:19pm

pretty nice we got Tomlinson as a frosh

Y05

5/24/16 12:00pm

Melvin Gordon, Wisconsin

Y05

5/24/16 12:57pm

Scott Mitchell !!!

IDAHO 4 Y

5/24/16 11:29am

Dwight Freeney

WhyaskY?

5/24/16 11:42am

Matt Ryan, Dennis Dixon (we beat his ducks..) are up there too

SouthernAZcoug

5/24/16 11:46am

I still have nightmares of Gaston Green

SpiffCoug

5/24/16 11:54am

JJ Stokes

Y05

5/24/16 12:31pm

Shawn Alexander Alabama

Y05

5/24/16 11:54am

Travis Wilson

Ghost

5/24/16 12:00pm

Eric Metcalf, Texas

Y05

5/24/16 12:08pm

chris weinke, florida Statr, another Heisman Trophy winner

Y05

5/24/16 12:17pm

Florida State roster check from 1991 and 2000

Y05

5/25/16 6:06am

was Mike Singletary on that 83 Baylor team?

Y05

5/24/16 12:22pm

No, drafted in NFL in 1981.

robin

5/24/16 2:26pm

Randall Cunningham was UNLV punter when we played in early 80s

Y05

5/24/16 12:23pm

make that back up 1981 was his freshman year

Y05

5/24/16 12:28pm

Chris Dolman, Bill Fralic both part of that 1984 Pitt team

Y05

5/24/16 12:42pm

Ironhead did his damage in the 1987 Pitt game.

BigD Coug

5/24/16 12:54pm

ASU's Danny White, Penn State's Blair Thomas

Rob of NV

5/24/16 12:57pm

need more ASU guys on this list, ASU went undefeated twice in the 70s

Y05

5/24/16 3:43pm

Herschel Walker

Bob Vance

5/24/16 1:15pm

Reggie Bush

rad dawg

5/24/16 1:24pm

I would put Brian Urlacher on the top of my list; that guy was a beast at NM

OGSuperfan

5/24/16 1:34pm

Dee Dowis...I was at that game...He ran all over BYU, but BYU still won the game..

deckard667

5/24/16 1:41pm

chad henning, outland trophy winner, and whoever was the star of the 1985 and

Y05

5/24/16 3:58pm

Eric Dickerson...

CoachSpeak

5/24/16 1:43pm

Russel Maryland, Eric Dickerson, Herschel Walker, Marshal Faulk

Accipiter

5/24/16 1:50pm

JJ Stokes. I was at the Rose Bowl watching him carry BYU defenders 20 yards...

byubananastand

5/24/16 2:10pm

according to this site: Walker #1 Olsen #38 Tomlinson #41 Bush #46 + Detmer #43.

robin

5/24/16 2:23pm

#36 Orlando Pace, Ohio St, 1993 Holiday Bowl, #35 Ryan Broyles, Oklahoma, 2009

Y05

5/24/16 5:02pm

Herschel Walker!

BYU Grounds

5/24/16 2:36pm

Bradlee Van Pelt

icecougar

5/24/16 2:57pm

this guy stuck in my memory too. Definitely gave byu all it could handle.

buckeyecougarguy

5/26/16 1:14pm

Shaun Alexander

erodcoug

5/24/16 3:40pm

Jonathan Ogden: I still remember when he came to Provo and DOMINATED

HarlemCoug

5/24/16 3:43pm

Any Yewt player, each of which runs a sub 4.3.

Real Men Wear Blue

5/24/16 3:57pm

Merlin Olson, or whoever the USU legend is

Y05

5/24/16 4:06pm

What this tells us is BYU has faced a lot of great players.

crimedog

5/24/16 4:53pm

and it says a lot about BYU because we beat a lot of them or took the game

Y05

5/25/16 4:52am

place kickers: Jason Elam, Hawaii, Jason Hanson, Washington State

Y05

5/24/16 5:08pm

Jerome Bettis, Elam, Van Pelt, Faulk, Dickerson, Bush, Dowis

shakarocks

5/24/16 5:27pm

I know this is a bit of joke now, but Colin Kaepernick killed us in 2010

CougarTail

5/24/16 5:28pm

I can't believe no one has mentioned DeMarco Murray.

bushy7

5/24/16 6:10pm

Thrill did

Y05

5/24/16 8:28pm

I'm a hack then....

bushy7

5/24/16 8:30pm

it's ok, a lot of hacks on this thread

Y05

5/25/16 4:50am

Didn't Aaron Rodgers play for CAL when BYU lost the Vegas bowl to them

Dat_rmishner

5/24/16 6:51pm

Nope.

BigD Coug

5/24/16 8:18pm

year after he left

Y05

5/24/16 8:26pm

Lynch has to be on the list somewhere.

Y'zFan

5/24/16 7:56pm

Easy! Beast Mode, Marshawn Lynch

BringYourUltimate

5/24/16 7:58pm

Andy Dalton in 2008. He killed my will to live. Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson famous

Bobmarleyjr

5/25/16 12:33am

Kevin Curtis, USU WR, was pretty dang good

Y05

5/25/16 4:42am

OJ McDuffie, PennState, Kerry Collins and Ki jana Carter all in 1992

Y05

5/25/16 6:14am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad