I guess my top 5 off the top of my head would be.....well, besides Les Mis which is my favorite, it may be easier to list those shows that I would rather see/that I like more than Hamilton. And admittedly, like food cravings, some of these will move around a bit depending on how long it has been since I have seen or listened to them etc... In no particular order:

Les Miserables
Wicked
Ragtime
Rent
Dear Evan Hanson
Memphis
Civil War
The Drowsy Chaperone (my favorite comedy)

So, I guess it does make it into my current top 10