I am guessing that the transfer issue works both ways

Jun 22, 2017
4:12:46pm

cougarmanguy All-American

For instance, other schools may also have received transfers but all three of the guys BYU received or transfers from schools with better recruiting classes than we had. I am guessing that other schools in front of us also had an attrition

Report problem with this ad

cougarmanguy

Bio page: cougarmanguy
Joined: Jul 10, 2012
Last login: Mar 15, 2020
Total posts: 73,268 (28,671 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

With Hoge, Empey, and Folau added to the 2015 class BYU's class ranking would have moved from #61 to #40

YIsForBrigham MYOB

6/22/17 3:18pm

Cool info. How did you do the calculations?

Harrison0Yfan

6/22/17 3:23pm

I used scout's formula and rankings

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 3:23pm

Using the same formula, a 2015 class composed of the top 25 LDS players would have been #24

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 3:25pm

Cool, nice work.

Harrison0Yfan

6/22/17 3:29pm

Did you just add their points, or did you also subtract the

Y'zFan

6/22/17 3:25pm

The 2015 class had enough room to add these players. No need to subtract other offers.

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 3:26pm

And to answer his other question, based on star points and position ranking pts.

Lip Gallagher

6/22/17 3:37pm

So dropping a few lower rated guys, would not have made much

Y'zFan

6/22/17 3:44pm

On Scout they only recorded 22 commits, so they would fit without

Lip Gallagher

6/22/17 4:01pm

Remember that returning missionaries sometimes count for their return year.

displacedute

6/22/17 4:24pm

That's true. This is more of an exercise to show how impressive these new players are and how much difference

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 7:49pm

Add Wayne Kirby to that as well. Big Transfer for Oregon

ayfan

6/22/17 3:48pm

Believe he was class of 2016 not 15

Martin Van Nostrand

6/22/17 4:04pm

*assuming no other teams had any transfers. Huge jump though.

BlueFrog

6/22/17 3:50pm

And also assuming all those guys went to byu (Charles west)

thebruce

6/22/17 4:03pm

Then you have to do the same thing for other programs.

Lip Gallagher

6/22/17 4:13pm

I agree, that's kinda what I'm getting at. It's cool to say

thebruce

6/22/17 4:44pm

Fair enough to make a point that it's a drastic change no matter what.

Lip Gallagher

6/22/17 5:01pm

I am guessing that the transfer issue works both ways

cougarmanguy

6/22/17 4:12pm

How many other teams have 3 high level transfers from 2015 that now have 5 to play 4?

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 4:52pm

Dunno. How many did not?

BlueFrog

6/22/17 4:54pm

I'm going to guess no one else

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 5:16pm

Do the research and get back to me. That's why I posted *assuming

BlueFrog

6/22/17 6:18pm

Lol

cougarmanguy

6/22/17 7:03pm

Looked it up. I was right

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 7:17pm

Cool. Good info. Thanks.

BlueFrog

6/22/17 7:18pm

I see it it's important for you to be condescending about subjects you are

cougarmanguy

6/22/17 7:30pm

Oh you again? Weren't you blasted on the last thread you piped up in?

BlueFrog

6/22/17 7:35pm

You must have me confused with every thread you've ever been in

cougarmanguy

6/22/17 7:39pm

Maybe it's that other Man guy

BlueFrog

6/22/17 8:33pm

If we can get a top 25 recruiting class, that would be a great compliment to

(Private)

6/22/17 4:42pm

Not this year.

displacedute

6/23/17 10:19am

did you add all of the transfers that every other program recieved?

coltonbyu

6/22/17 4:59pm

3 of those 4 are not transfers.

YIsForBrigham

6/22/17 5:17pm

how do you figure?

coltonbyu

6/23/17 10:25am

They never enrolled as they went straight on missions.

JDBlue

6/23/17 10:30am

fine. 'did you add all of the other late commits that every other program got?'

coltonbyu

6/23/17 10:37am

How does that compare to The other Utah-based schools?

theozfam

6/22/17 6:25pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad