A big step down? No, they would be taking a small step sideways.

Report problem with this ad

Oct 19, 2017
3:25:53pm

Polecat All-American

Report problem with this ad

Polecat

Previous username: kabslc
Bio page: Polecat
Joined: Jan 21, 2013
Last login: May 21, 2024
Total posts: 9,205 (189 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU should ABSOLUTELY join the AAC. It's the right fit, it's the right time...

46in96

10/19/17 12:07pm

Or MWC. Independence is a sinking ship.

Blueto

10/19/17 12:09pm

BYU will never go back to the MWC

-C9-

10/19/17 12:09pm

<< Deleted >>

Cretin

10/19/17 12:11pm

Agree on the sinking ship part. Indy, MWC, and AAC both end up in the same place

RoyalCoug99

10/19/17 12:11pm

It's the honest truth? Lol.

Turnpike Lane

10/19/17 12:15pm

Then discuss it with me. Don't just scoff at what I said.

RoyalCoug99

10/19/17 1:40pm

Here's the interview I did with Mike this summer

bcriddle

10/19/17 6:54pm

TH should be on the phone NOW! This ship sinks anymore and BYU will be lucky to

blackshirts

10/19/17 7:22pm

Keep beating that drum

Turnpike Lane

10/19/17 12:12pm

Same for those who think Indy = relevance. Dead horse.

46in96

10/19/17 12:14pm

There's a right time to cancel 20+ P5/G5 games and incur $10MM+ in penalties? Cool.

mulletino

10/19/17 12:16pm

Yup. There sure is. There's a right time to do a lot of things that hurt

46in96

10/19/17 12:19pm

$20 million dollars will be worthless in 10 years? What sort of hyperinflation

GhostofPostersPast

10/19/17 12:43pm

We will not play 3 P5 games a year if we join a G5. It will not happen.

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 12:16pm

And if we join a G5 who cares if we play any P5 schools?

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 12:18pm

We always cared before, I don't see why we would stop.

Polecat

10/19/17 2:03pm

Different world. And if we are going back to g5 we are admitting we can’t handle it. May as well just pad our ego

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 2:25pm

It's a fundamental difference of perspective... I don't see Indy with 8-7 games

46in96

10/19/17 2:38pm

Sure but those of you that continue to say that Indy schedules are just a G5 schedule with 3 P5 games are ignoring our

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 2:51pm

Can't handle what? BYU is not in a P5 and is not going to be. Independence is

Polecat

10/19/17 2:54pm

Independence is as close to P5 as BYU can get in college football without being

GhostofPostersPast

10/19/17 2:56pm

The thing is it's still not very close, and BYU fans are the only people who

Polecat

10/19/17 3:25pm

Depends on your definition of close

GhostofPostersPast

10/19/17 4:04pm

A big step down? No, they would be taking a small step sideways.

Polecat

10/19/17 3:25pm

We just went 3-3 against P5 last year. 3 losses were by mere points. Combined.

MarylandFan

10/20/17 4:54am

1-13 against winning P5 teams.

blackshirts

10/20/17 7:10am

You're right, BYU can't handle it. If you enjoy being ARMY and UMASS you're in

blackshirts

10/19/17 3:10pm

If that’s the case, then let’s be sure to not schedule any P5 teams

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 3:12pm

We already start the year with 3 P5s

SaintGeorgeYFan

10/19/17 4:03pm

And that won’t happen in a G5. No G5 does that. No G5 has ever done that.

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 9:25pm

So? Just because no one ever has - big deal? 8 conf games leaves 4 open

46in96

10/19/17 9:28pm

It won’t happen because it can’t. You don’t have enough flexibility to make it happen.

YIsForBrigham

10/19/17 9:59pm

Have we not started the season with 3 straight P5s before? Before said P5s start

46in96

10/19/17 10:05pm

Beating that dead horse again. Bravo.

gww687

10/19/17 12:21pm

Basketball would be more fun to watch IMO as well.

NorCal Cougar

10/19/17 12:22pm

That would be an AWESOME b-ball conf!

46in96

10/19/17 12:24pm

RE: BYU should ABSOLUTELY join the AAC. It's the right fit, it's the right

svenot

10/19/17 12:35pm

It would be cheaper to pay more for a new coach

2FarGone

10/19/17 12:38pm

RE: BYU should ABSOLUTELY join the AAC. It's the right fit, it's the right time...

BlueVU

10/19/17 12:55pm

Nice try, but Indy Bro is far beyond convincing at this point

CougarinOZ

10/19/17 3:03pm

INDY supporters are just insecure people that can't handle Utey fans calling

blackshirts

10/19/17 3:23pm

THIS ^^^^

46in96

10/19/17 3:37pm

Wow.. then screw the AAC. Let's see if the Big Sky will take us!

SLIVER

10/19/17 3:56pm

Did you read the post?

blackshirts

10/19/17 4:37pm

I wish I hadn't. I feel much dumber now.

SLIVER

10/20/17 9:28am

You can be 'dumber' or 'more dumb', but you can't be "much dumber".

46in96

10/20/17 9:40am

Completely agree. After reading what you and blackshirts are vomiting out..

SLIVER

10/20/17 3:34pm

Yeah, let's go DIII, baby!! Whoo Whoo!!

ArchbishopMitty

10/19/17 4:42pm

Tell me how Indy is working? Use facts like better recruting, rankings, respect

blackshirts

10/19/17 5:28pm

You got nothing!

blackshirts

10/20/17 7:13am

Who are you people, and what have you done with normal CBers?

AZcougLawyer

10/19/17 4:33pm

Don't see our version of indy as better than G5...

46in96

10/19/17 5:07pm

Not a fan of backslide G5 conf idea, but I’d prefer the rivalries &

MatthiasG

10/19/17 4:48pm

What about basketball?

Cougtruth

10/19/17 5:58pm

WCC is a D2 plus GU

blackshirts

10/19/17 7:02pm

So BYU fans will get more excited about games

CougarWildcat

10/19/17 6:17pm

Ummm.... let's see...

46in96

10/19/17 6:32pm

UH fans sure suck. Look at their attendance right now

Y4LYFE

10/19/17 6:36pm

Only 3 ways out of Indy: 1) P5 invite 2) Big12 implodes & new conf w/ leftovers

BamaCoug

10/19/17 7:14pm

Your #2 and #3 are possible and not mutually exclusive with joining AAC now, but

46in96

10/19/17 7:46pm

Bingo

BYUSwoop

10/20/17 5:22pm

Agreed

RedUte

10/19/17 9:32pm

You would.

Posting on CougarBoard