I don't see the losses as coming close to outstripping the gains. Losing the Kump commitment really hurts, but that's on the terrible mismanagement of the HC Office, not Kalani.
I think that getting Khyris, Hoge, Kirby, Empey will be a huge gain compared to the few losses we've had.
This season has been terrible, but if recruiting doesn't tank and we can keep Kaho, Romney and the others then Kalani deserves credit for recruiting.