If BYU strung together five NCAA tournament championships in a row, I think the excitement would be off the charts. This may be sacrilegious, but I think the buzz heading into and through the third, fourth, and fifth seasons would exceed Jimmeresque, getting bigger each year.
I don’t care what is going on in the rest of the country or Utah at that time, during that stretch, basketball would be king at BYU. Unless BYU is playing championship football at that time too.