First Contact, then Wrath of Kahn, then Search for Spock, then IV, then Generations, and everything is not worth a watch

May 6, 2024
2:35:08pm

jacobugath INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

Report problem with this ad

jacobugath

Previous username: byujacob
Bio page: jacobugath
Joined: Apr 15, 2008
Last login: May 27, 2024
Total posts: 68,277 (8,043 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

How would you rank the Star Trek films?

TNT

May 6, 1:45pm

a "x" way tie for last

fulano

May 6, 1:47pm

I would rank them best to worst

Texas Hammer

May 6, 1:48pm

Ugh. TNT's sarcasm policy has come back to haunt him

TNT

May 6, 1:48pm

I would rank them first by film length (spoiler, there's a tie), then by villain

Doogal McCougar

May 6, 1:52pm

I wouldn't.

shoganai

May 6, 1:48pm

The one with dementors was best.

The Pope

May 6, 1:49pm

Ahhh...the Phantom Menace.... Good call.

BYUtka

May 6, 1:54pm

First Contact lives up to its namesake.

BlueVU

May 6, 1:49pm

Good movie

TNT

May 6, 1:52pm

That one where dark vader says he's the kid's father is probably best. Pretty

Florida Man

May 6, 1:49pm

That's called "The Half Blood Prince." It's pretty good.

BYUtka

May 6, 1:54pm

Here's the definitive ranking:

WorfoSAUR

May 6, 1:50pm

Wait. You rank Into Darkness last? Offense = accepted

TNT

May 6, 1:51pm

It's a terrible movie

WorfoSAUR

May 6, 2:01pm

It seems like I'm the only person who likes Into Darkness

mannheimadler

May 6, 2:03pm

We enjoyed it. There are certainly valid criticisms, but it is fun.

BYUtka

May 6, 2:05pm

I enjoy all of them (including Into Darkness), but it ranks pretty low for me.

durandal

May 6, 2:20pm

I enjoyed it, but it’s hard to disassociate it from Wrath of Khan. And the

Faceman

May 6, 2:27pm

Machete order.

joelvandyne

May 6, 1:51pm

Gosh dang it

TNT

May 6, 1:52pm

Even numbered TOS movies>First two reboots and First Contact>The rest of them.

Bandit

May 6, 1:52pm

That's actually a great summary. You sir deserve a POTD

TNT

May 6, 1:53pm

RE: That's actually a great summary. You sir deserve a POTD

Bandit

May 6, 1:54pm

My rankings based on how I feel today:

Faceman

May 6, 1:55pm

TNT will accept this list

TNT

May 6, 1:59pm

RE: TNT will accept this list

Faceman

May 6, 2:08pm

Lucas made 3 good, great good films, and then 3 okish/bad films

Coug

May 6, 1:56pm

TNT will not accept this list

TNT

May 6, 1:59pm

RE: TNT will not accept this list

Coug

May 6, 2:01pm

TNG made a better series. TOS had better films.

Corn Pop

May 6, 1:59pm

13. Insurrection. 12. Final Frontier 11. Beyond 10. Nemesis 9. Generations

mannheimadler

May 6, 2:02pm

II, VI, I, IV, III, V

777

May 6, 2:05pm

I'm pretty offended you haven't acknowledged my bold #3 pick.

777

May 6, 9:28pm

Would be hard to put together a definitive list. But XII is definitely at the top and it goes down from there.

RalphWiggam

May 6, 2:12pm

RE: How would you rank the Star Trek films?

durandal

May 6, 2:19pm

VI is way too low on your list.

BYUtka

May 6, 2:26pm

Your placement of V is fair. VI is way too low.

Ungoy

May 6, 2:59pm

We've been watching them recently as a family. We haven't watched

BYUtka

May 6, 2:25pm

Prodigy gets better with each episode. By the end of the season, I think it comes into its own as a Trek series.

durandal

May 6, 2:28pm

First Contact, then Wrath of Kahn, then Search for Spock, then IV, then Generations, and everything is not worth a watch

jacobugath

May 6, 2:35pm

VI is absolutely worth watching. Arguably the best film in the series.

BYUtka

May 6, 2:42pm

#1 Wrath of Khan.

BlueFever

May 6, 2:46pm

My rankings from best to worst:

Ungoy

May 6, 2:50pm

My rankings:

Posting on CougarBoard