My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 20, 2024
12:52
:14
pm
Jdoc
All-American
I missed that. That would change my attitude about it as well since he wasn't
trying to kill the Grizzly. Although, even if he was trying to kill the Grizzly, I would still feel bad for him and especially his wife and children.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Jdoc
Bio page
Jdoc
Joined
Feb 8, 2018
Last login
Jun 2, 2024
Total posts
10,548 (19 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Do you consider it a tragedy when an animal being hunted kills or injures the
Jdoc
May 20, 12:03pm
he was going to feed his family for a full year with that bear meat.
claw
May 20, 12:05pm
He survived so he probably still can since the bear died.
Jdoc
May 20, 12:06pm
Are you making that assumption? The article does not mention that. Many
Jdoc
May 20, 12:08pm
RE: Are you making that assumption? The article does not mention that. Many
claw
May 20, 12:13pm
People don’t eat Grizzly bear meat.
ArcticKat
May 20, 12:21pm
Yes they do, lol
Jericho
May 20, 12:37pm
200 yrs ago more people lived off bear meat than deer meat
Tricky
May 20, 1:13pm
That was probably almost 100% black bear meat. There might have been browns
ArcticKat
May 20, 2:12pm
I think this guy was hunting black bear. I know you were talking about grizz
Tricky
May 20, 5:47pm
He was attacked by a grizzly. Didn’t realize he was hunting black bears. Despite
ArcticKat
May 20, 7:20pm
The comments were about grizzlies and that’s what I was responding to. People
ArcticKat
May 20, 1:50pm
Some people do. Cam Hanes does I know that.
Penske Material
May 20, 12:38pm
Stew
BYU Grounds
May 20, 1:55pm
From what I know of hunting, you can only carry 100 lbs back to your camp.
Mems
May 20, 12:30pm
And apparently you're only allowed to take one load?
Eddie
May 20, 12:33pm
Yeah, kinda. But... being hurt while hunting a grizzly?
Courtimedes
May 20, 12:07pm
Sure. Lot's of tragedy happens when people are doing dangerous stuff.
JAGA97
May 20, 12:07pm
Isn’t trophy hunting kind of about the danger?
spinner
May 20, 12:08pm
Nope. Turnabout is fair play.
BYUtka
May 20, 12:09pm
Not a huge "tragedy" when someone engages in dangerous behavior and gets hurt.
CatamountFan
May 20, 12:13pm
Animal beings have rights too.
Sea Chicken
May 20, 12:13pm
The right to taste good, right to be grilled or baked or sauted. Lots of rights
OldFogey
May 20, 12:37pm
Yeah, humans matter more than any animal
Jericho
May 20, 12:14pm
some of us do, at least
Digital Gangsta
May 20, 12:19pm
they need to upgrade their hunting dogs
Digital Gangsta
May 20, 12:15pm
Not a fan of hunting bear with dogs.
TheHop
May 20, 12:25pm
Depends on how the animal identifies.
Longseason
May 20, 12:18pm
It’s a tragedy for the wife and kids he leave behind. I feel bad for them that their husband/dad died
RealTaysomHill
May 20, 12:20pm
The hunter did not die.
TheHop
May 20, 12:24pm
“Do you consider it a tragedy when the animal kills or injures the hunter.” Feel free to include “or injures” in my post
RealTaysomHill
May 20, 12:35pm
The bear left him alive so to serve as an example to the rest of us.
ochobeeguy
May 20, 1:02pm
Taking risks doesn't mean you deserve to meet a bad fate
Jericho
May 20, 12:46pm
Yes, I definitely said taking risks means someone deserves death.
RealTaysomHill
May 20, 2:05pm
lol, so many bad takes in on post
Jericho
May 20, 2:53pm
I'll leave the grizz alone and keep my distance
Cougrrrs Roll
May 20, 12:23pm
There are different kinds of tragedies, to be sure.
Eddie
May 20, 12:27pm
The way you asked this question says a lot IMO
FiveTen-BuckEighty
May 20, 12:32pm
Yikes. Did you really ask that?
Benfica1
May 20, 12:33pm
To be clear - he was hunting black bear and not grizzly (which is what attacked him).
Penske Material
May 20, 12:34pm
Ah... Ok... That is a bit different. I change my vote.
BYUtka
May 20, 12:39pm
I missed that. That would change my attitude about it as well since he wasn't
Jdoc
May 20, 12:52pm
Play stupid games.
scootsy
May 20, 12:57pm
As a hunter, I don't consider a tragedy or otherwise. No. Is it more of a traged
hadmonster
May 20, 1:38pm
First of all these hunts are to cull the herd so that the population can survive. Yes, it is a tragedy bc a human was
BYU Grounds
May 20, 1:57pm
Would your opinion change if a human
Jdoc
May 20, 2:06pm
Not my favorite statement - "animals are here for our use"
hadmonster
May 20, 2:32pm
as long as stewarding involves eating them, you betcha
Digital Gangsta
May 20, 2:34pm
It does.
John Doe
May 20, 2:38pm
of course, but doesn't mean they should suffer before they are harvested
hadmonster
May 20, 2:52pm
that seems like a vague criticism that may not be based on an entirely
Digital Gangsta
May 20, 2:57pm
I can tell you that some animals I have taken died almost immediately, others
hadmonster
May 20, 3:03pm
ah, I mis-guessed and falsely assumed your overall meaning
Digital Gangsta
May 20, 3:09pm
animals are here for our benefit
BYU Grounds
May 20, 3:45pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad