I don’t think it’s Indy that has failed. It’s the teams. Much of that has been due to inconsistent QB play. A lot of that has been bad luck (several season ending injuries). One could argue I guess this is due to tougher schedules but just looking at Taysom, his injuries were three against USU and a non-contact injury against Nebraska.
To say it failed because we suck isn’t a great argument for returning to a G5.