And apparently I'm a hack.

Report problem with this ad

Mar 20, 2019
8:58:26am

Scratch All-American

And apparently I'm a hack.

Report problem with this ad

Scratch

Bio page: Scratch
Joined: Jan 14, 2004
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 12,334 (374 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Which player do you pick only considering batting stats and guess who they are. This covers their first 8 seasons.

Baron There was no collusion

3/20/19 8:44am

obviously very close, but you have to take player 2, no?

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 8:48am

But can you guess who it is? It surprised me.

Baron

3/20/19 8:49am

are these active players?

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 8:50am

One is active.

Baron

3/20/19 8:51am

I'd be interested in seeing the same comparison with pujols first 8.

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 8:55am

Here you go and arguably better.

Baron

3/20/19 9:01am

dang

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 9:58am

RE: But can you guess who it is? It surprised me.

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 8:52am

1 for 2.

Baron

3/20/19 8:53am

<< Deleted >>

smokymountainrain

3/20/19 8:53am

<< Deleted >>

Baron

3/20/19 8:53am

Which would you prefer?

3/20/19 8:49am

RE: Which would you prefer?

3/20/19 8:55am

Obviously it seems like player 2 has a slight edge, but I'd be interested in

Martin Van Nostrand

3/20/19 8:49am

Answers

Baron

3/20/19 8:51am

Just looked him up again...he was a monster, for sure

Martin Van Nostrand

3/20/19 8:56am

RE: Answers

3/20/19 8:58am

Cool post. Super interesting stuff. Frank Thomas was the man.

Vincent's Picks

3/20/19 9:10am

Player 2 has the edge.

Hotty-Toddy-Reb

3/20/19 8:50am

Player is 2 better at everything. 1 is bonds, 2 pujols?

ayfan

3/20/19 8:50am

You also have to keep in mind that Trout did that in his age 19-26 seasons.

Scratch

3/20/19 8:57am

And apparently I'm a hack.

Scratch

3/20/19 8:58am

The point was more of highlighting how great the second player was.

Baron

3/20/19 9:06am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad