It's fine to not sugar coat his performance and say it wasn't great last year. It wasn't. He looked lost and out of place frequently, but he has to be given some benefit that he was off for the year before and the first 1/4 of the season. I didn't like his play and gave him hard time for it this year because I still expected better from him.
Having said that, there's no question he's one of, or can be, a top 5 player for us next year. For anyone to say he's losing his scholarship or what not is just silly.
I've taken the first few posts of people saying he's gone as jokes, but now we've got people actually believing it and "feeling" like he's gone. Those feelings wouldn't be there were it not for a few random comments from anonymous users on CB. Man we look silly as a fan base some times.