Those two losses are indicative of the struggles the team has had under Kilani. He has little to no margin for error because of those losses. We will still end the year wondering when BYU will stop losing to multiple teams we should beat, some really bad. So he is already in a hole there this year.

I like the rivalry wins, but I would rather have a great record than a rivalry win. So the article focuses too much on that for me as well. I think overall win % should be emphasized more for "Kilani's quest." But I may not be your target audience, since I live outside of Utah.

Thanks for the write up. I like all BYU articles, that don't give back handed compliments or outright slam the church or the school. Also, I am impressed that you post it here directly and brave the Internet message board "feedback."