FWIW-- Sagarin has us at 53 and the Fremeau efficiency index has us at 62.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 13, 2019
9:18:59am

jkccoug All-American

FWIW-- Sagarin has us at 53 and the Fremeau efficiency index has us at 62.

Report problem with this ad

jkccoug

New username: Socrates Johnson
Bio page: jkccoug
Joined: Jul 19, 2002
Last login: Oct 13, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU coaches are roughly average this year. Last year was quite a bit better.

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:12am

Grimes is improving and Roderick is doing a nice job. Tuiaki has been bad as has Mateo. They’re both underperforming

Pimpin4Paradise

11/13/19 9:13am

Offensive and defensive S&P don't differ much. O = 68 and D = 77.

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:17am

With a 3rd string QB at that

ldssdl

11/13/19 9:40am

Grimes has digressed but everyone loves him and gives him a pass. He has been

idacoug

11/13/19 9:25am

Regressed maybe?

LaserCoug

11/13/19 9:36am

Not to mention, Grimes is only in year 2 of establishing his offense and

ldssdl

11/13/19 9:40am

Do you have the actual S&P formula?

Genghis Spreads

11/13/19 9:16am

Bill Connelly's old website (before he went to ESPN) has it (link)

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:25am

It doesn't say how much he weights those factors. I'm guessing it's proprietary.

Genghis Spreads

11/13/19 9:27am

Probably

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:32am

Recruiting class rankings are too noisy to do that

Coop

11/13/19 9:17am

That is my biggest issue. Recruit rankings are too subjective

Cougar TD

11/13/19 9:20am

I thought that too, but I saw a guy who used just recruiting and a "coaching"

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:22am

Dave bartoo

cougaman

11/13/19 9:31am

That's the guy. Can't find a legit website for him.

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:33am

He interviews fairly regularly with Portland radio station. He uses recruiting

cougaman

11/13/19 9:39am

Over time you would get some reliable coach quality data though

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:41am

I think they can give you a very general idea however. Long term if you out-

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:23am

I think that coaching is slightly better this year — especially on offense.

Benfica1

11/13/19 9:17am

Offense has been better in the past few games

Brigham

11/13/19 9:53am

FWIW-- Sagarin has us at 53 and the Fremeau efficiency index has us at 62.

jkccoug

11/13/19 9:18am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad