Hall.
1. We have NO idea how Romney or Hall would do against the competition we have seen. But we do know this: Romney looked good last year in actual game time, better than Zach.
2. Zach has been awesome so far this season. He has shown improvement in his decision making and accuracy. He reads the field better and make quick decisions when needed. The schedule has been very poor, but he has been great.
How someone can look at those 2 items and then decide to mock a BYU player who has done nothing but help win games is crazy to me.