I get it. I’m saying it’s a hard pill to swallow.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 4, 2022
7:17:10pm

Jdoc All-American

I get it. I’m saying it’s a hard pill to swallow.

Report problem with this ad

Jdoc

Bio page: Jdoc
Joined: Feb 8, 2018
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 10,582 (19 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

MLB Contemporary HOF Committee elects Fred McGriff to the Hall of Fame. Nobody else.

TCuz Disgraced Rules President

12/4/22 6:10pm

Dang, was hoping we'd get two more Braves in today, not just one.

ATLCoug2088

12/4/22 6:12pm

6/16 votes for Murphy. 12 needed for election. Sigh.

ugo1st

12/4/22 6:18pm

🙏🙏🙏 thank you voters! 🙏🙏🙏

shimmy

12/4/22 6:19pm

If you dominate the game for a decade, you

Jdoc

12/4/22 6:24pm

Definitely in the hall or pretty good and the hall for good guys. Great career.

shimmy

12/4/22 6:27pm

But Advanced Stats, which show that Mike Trout literally walks on water, say no

TrackCoug

12/4/22 6:41pm

This, but unironically.

TCuz

12/4/22 6:44pm

Make an argument based on his old stats that aren't an arbitrary time period then.

shimmy

12/4/22 6:45pm

You mean make an argument that fits your criteria, which you don’t disclose

TrackCoug

12/4/22 6:53pm

2000 hits and 400 homers .265/.346./.469. 46 WAR. Really good career. Not HOF. I’m sorry you see it differently than

shimmy

12/4/22 7:10pm

I can respect that you disagree that he should be in. It is hard for many of his

Jdoc

12/4/22 7:13pm

The standard shouldn’t be “better than the worst HOFers.” I agree there are people worse than him in the hall.

shimmy

12/4/22 7:16pm

I get it. I’m saying it’s a hard pill to swallow.

Jdoc

12/4/22 7:17pm

I get it. If the committee that voted on Kenny lofton keeps him out we riot.

shimmy

12/4/22 7:18pm

It is a tough pill to swallow

TrackCoug

12/4/22 7:28pm

What is more impressive, a player that accumulates above average numbers for

Jdoc

12/4/22 7:00pm

Then use averages and not a time frame that gives him hundreds of extra games

Plato

12/4/22 7:08pm

Dale didn’t have 5 seasons like Koufax. If you think Koufax should be out, go for it.

shimmy

12/4/22 7:13pm

I don’t think Koufax should be out. He was

Jdoc

12/4/22 7:16pm

I'm surprised at the Schilling decision. I thought the committee would put him in for sure. The Crimedog may get the

shimmy

12/4/22 6:18pm

The writer’s ballot is so barren right now after years of having too many options.

TCuz

12/4/22 6:20pm

Not sure why you’re so high on Schilling. 216 wins and career 3.46 ERA

chitownboy

12/4/22 6:34pm

Thank you for using wins and ERA in this post. The worst numbers was the cherry on top. Have a good evening.

shimmy

12/4/22 6:39pm

Uh they are the 2nd worst career numbers of any in the hall.

chitownboy

12/4/22 7:33pm

Well deserved for McGriff. I cannot believe the baseball writers did not

Jdoc

12/4/22 6:19pm

They randomly cut the vote process from 15 down to 10 years, and he was constantly on loaded ballots

TCuz

12/4/22 6:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad