I hope this wasn't an experiment on following instructions.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 29, 2014
1:24:35pm

Shimmy

I hope this wasn't an experiment on following instructions.

Report problem with this ad

Shimmy

Previous username: AFCoug83
Bio page: Shimmy
Joined: Jan 15, 2008
Last login: Jun 16, 2024
Total posts: 118,129 (37,189 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

a moral thought experiment:

erkimust

7/29/14 12:36pm

<< Deleted >>

Buffalo

7/29/14 12:37pm

This is pretty easy actually. If I knew that this would be the only time this

Mister P

7/29/14 12:40pm

I will not do anything until he starts shooting and endangering/killing innocent

ol' Blue Eyes

7/29/14 12:44pm

I'd say you are jointly and severally culpable with the criminal

Shimmy

7/29/14 12:45pm

<< Deleted >>

erkimust

7/29/14 12:50pm

Well, if he can't hit me from that distance. Then I just wait.

Mikey

7/29/14 12:45pm

I grab my own hostage.

purplmonkeydishwashr

7/29/14 12:47pm

The Greenrake approach to Mexican Standoffs. I like it.

Byron McNertney

7/29/14 12:50pm

I wait and do nothing. As we are not in a gun free zone, I'm sure that some

Louis Litt

7/29/14 12:52pm

this is a valuable, worthwhile thought experiment

BYUCoug11

7/29/14 12:54pm

Not really, as it has a major flaw in the scenario

valcorger

7/29/14 1:15pm

Why are you responsible for their protection?

Byron McNertney

7/29/14 1:17pm

Because I'm the one between him and them and have the assets to protect them

valcorger

7/29/14 1:29pm

Well, if I ever learned anything from a Keanu Reeves movie its this:

BE-WHY-YOU

7/29/14 12:56pm

incorrect. shoot into the air while crying out in emotional pain.

erkimust

7/29/14 12:56pm

Ok... so I assume my assailant is a midget, otherwise I would be able to blast

IrishBlue

7/29/14 12:59pm

what IrishBlue would really do:

BYUCoug11

7/29/14 1:02pm

Well, I didn't know I had an uzi for both hands...

IrishBlue

7/29/14 1:07pm

You are forgetting that Greedo shot first in the recut.

Shimmy

7/29/14 1:03pm

One of the worst movie decisions of all time.

7/29/14 1:52pm

Do I know the kid? Do I like the kid? Also,

2RUEBLUE

7/29/14 1:04pm

Well, first I'd ignore your conditions and create my own so I could answer a

DapperDan

7/29/14 1:04pm

Or...as I've learned in movies, I shoot through the child's shoulder which goes

ol' Blue Eyes

7/29/14 1:05pm

I personally don't shoot in that circumstance unless I cannot retreat and it

cheezedawg

7/29/14 1:06pm

Haha. CB ignores the question and fantasizes their John McClane heroism

jokerman

7/29/14 1:08pm

Shimmy didnt answer the question. He didnt speak to the moral culpability, only

cheezedawg

7/29/14 1:12pm

Well, I gave my answer to moral culpability in legal terms.

Shimmy

7/29/14 3:19pm

Answering this question as framed doesn't require thought, unless you are a

Louis Litt

7/29/14 1:17pm

There is no decision to be made in his scenario

jokerman

7/29/14 1:45pm

I'm sorry, I'll rephrase so it's clear that the "moral dilemma" is addressed:

Louis Litt

7/29/14 3:43pm

I'd just pull a "James T. Kirk" and reprogram the test...

TheDeek

7/29/14 1:11pm

You are already dead

AxelDC

7/29/14 1:11pm

I wouldn't blame someone who took either approach.

QuinneyCoug

7/29/14 1:37pm

I hope this wasn't an experiment on following instructions.

Shimmy

7/29/14 1:24pm

Easy, my life isn't more valuable than an innocent child, I back off

mosterlow

7/29/14 1:49pm

100%

Bergloewe

7/29/14 1:57pm

Like all CBers, I'm awesome enough that something like this would happen (video)

mr_thekid

7/29/14 3:36pm

Well, here goes...

7/29/14 4:51pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad