OP doesn't say "throwing" comparison. Says QB comparison.

Sep 23, 2014
4:22:21pm

Cougarclaw

Pretty awesome how close the stats are when you take out hills biggest strength that you don't even pay lip service to in you "QB compare". It's misleading.

Report problem with this ad

Cougarclaw

Previous username: BigWoodThunder
Bio page: Cougarclaw
Joined: Jun 22, 2011
Last login: Jun 18, 2024
Total posts: 60,151 (15,118 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Wilson vs Hill comparison:

byujacob

9/23/14 3:38pm

So, basically Wilson is a better QB

Bob Vance

9/23/14 3:40pm

Would you pick Wilson over Taysom?

byujacob

9/23/14 3:41pm

I assumed you knew I was being sarcastic. Can I get a yewt-no on the question

Bob Vance

9/23/14 3:43pm

For BYU's offense, no.

sheriffcreg

9/23/14 3:52pm

Good QB playing against poor competition

byusage

9/23/14 3:41pm

"Poor" is being generous. I think UT, UVa, and Houston would all beat Michigan

ldssdl

9/23/14 3:48pm

We have played #8, #11, and #44 in Pass Eff. D. Utah played FCS, #125, & #59.

jkccoug

9/23/14 4:15pm

Opponents are a relevant statistic.

Chester Copperpot

9/23/14 3:41pm

to this point, Utah has had a very easy road.

Belboz

9/23/14 3:51pm

Utah played Idaho state...t

idcougarfan

9/23/14 3:41pm

you forgot a very important and telling stat line

zonacougar

9/23/14 3:42pm

LOL

Twin Roots

9/23/14 3:56pm

Idaho St. = Savannah, Fresno St. = UNLV We haven't played our cupcakes yet

Twin Roots

9/23/14 3:45pm

That comparison without including rushing yards & TDs is very incomplete.

refunder

9/23/14 3:46pm

It depends on what you're looking at. This is just looking at throwing.

byujacob

9/23/14 3:50pm

OP doesn't say "throwing" comparison. Says QB comparison.

Cougarclaw

9/23/14 4:22pm

I wasn't trying to be misleading about anything.

byujacob

9/23/14 7:49pm

Fresno has not given up less than 52 points in their 3 games against FBS teams

Bronoc

9/23/14 3:46pm

FSU is #125 in pass efficiency d. Dead last in FBS.

jkccoug

9/23/14 4:16pm

Taysom has a higher QBR ranking. #18 to #24.

lawboy

9/23/14 3:46pm

Exactly. As though being an elite RB at the same time is a negative.

mulletino

9/23/14 4:00pm

Wilson sucks, Hill is awesome. All I know.

Zaphod

9/23/14 3:47pm

Courting controversy huh? Didn't you know Taysom is better than Steve Young?

mikeynolikey

9/23/14 3:47pm

That leaves out some important numbers:

AndyDwyer

9/23/14 3:59pm

Both are good QB's for their respective strengths. What I see when watching

UneducatedFan

9/23/14 4:00pm

Defenses played against explains a lot of the variance.

jkccoug

9/23/14 4:13pm

Would you like to reword that: Savannah St. and Middle Tennessee

Blue Ghost

9/23/14 4:44pm

It will change as we play more cupcakes and they play some decent teams, yes.

jkccoug

9/23/14 4:47pm

We will see if you're singing that tuned at the end of the season.

Virginia Ute

9/23/14 6:49pm

what about this stat?

Posting on CougarBoard