Plug that into the scout and rivals rating formula and see where it ends up

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Feb 4, 2017
9:37:33am

Bob Vance All-American

Plug that into the scout and rivals rating formula and see where it ends up

Report problem with this ad

Bob Vance

Bio page: Bob Vance
Joined: Feb 13, 2006
Last login: Jun 19, 2024
Total posts: 51,761 (7,124 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU recruiting class adjusted for returned missionaries, new players & transfers

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:12am

Nice list - you missed my favorite player Mo Langi....

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:14am

edited - thanks

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:15am

LOL - love the zero star ranking.... He's going to be the first zero star guy to play in the NFL....

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:18am

Except for the dozen or so guys that are currently in the NFL? And the 100's before?

BlueFrog

2/4/17 9:22am

there are no zero star guys... unrated guys get 2 stars. A zero star rating would connote that his skills were

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:24am

Fine he was NR but no stars were next to that sooo

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:28am

Weird rating system. Is it possible to get 1 star?

Hambone

2/4/17 9:40am

I'm a middle-aged man with no discernable skills and apparently I get two stars.

byujdmba

2/4/17 9:48am

Me too. Let's start a team.

svenot

2/4/17 10:06am

Kinda like gymnastics, where it's almost impossible to get less than 7 out of 10

Zapata

2/4/17 12:09pm

Interesting. Not according to Dick Harmon. (link)

BYU-Ite

2/4/17 1:18pm

Link to any player with a zero star ranking? 2 is the lowest.

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 1:48pm

No. I was just saying that Dick Harmon said he had zero stars. I'm not arguing

BYU-Ite

2/4/17 3:37pm

Ziggy

thebruce

2/4/17 9:22am

I didn't rank him just in case you were wondering

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:27am

sorry to highjack the thread and make it about Mo. This discussion should be about Kalani and the great group of

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:29am

I would have included them but both have played

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:37am

Longson was around all of last year. Not sure he should count.

2/4/17 9:18am

he redshirted so he's new this year...

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:20am

Even better yeah?

grosven

2/4/17 9:23am

agreed - great to have guys back after a redshirt year spent in the program.

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 9:25am

In that case you're missing guys, like Zac Dawe and Fuiava as well.

southernfriedcougar

2/4/17 9:56am

Thanks

BigYfan

2/4/17 10:01am

Plug that into the scout and rivals rating formula and see where it ends up

Bob Vance

2/4/17 9:37am

One of them only take the top 20 highest I believe

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:42am

Average of 3.04* (assuming Mo is a 2*) - tied for 32nd in ave * (utes 3.14)

dryflyelk

2/4/17 9:37am

nice, thanks

BigYfan

2/4/17 9:40am

And there are still some available transfers that are a BYU lean... could be good.

HarlemCoug

2/4/17 10:07am

Would they be:

beauso79

2/4/17 11:32am

James Empey and Gabe Reid

scott715

2/4/17 12:24pm

I wouldn't include Reid in that

southernfriedcougar

2/4/17 12:34pm

Forgot about Empey for some reason....

beauso79

2/4/17 1:31pm

Not bad at all.

2/4/17 5:03pm

You forgot Takitaki

2/4/17 10:47am

If you're including new guys like Longson and Leiataua, Isaiah Kaufusi could be

pinolero

2/4/17 11:00am

Great work. Can you please add position?

8theU

2/4/17 11:32am

Will do

BigYfan

2/4/17 2:28pm

Only 25 (max) initials available. You have 28. How does that work?

LiquidUte

2/4/17 12:21pm

Several of them were initial counters last year.

pinolero

2/4/17 12:28pm

Looking at Scout, I put it about #37 on par with TCU

scott715

2/4/17 12:22pm

Too many variables. Stars are just one portion of a score.

southernfriedcougar

2/4/17 12:32pm

Also looking forward to Lotulelei at WR who was a RS. 3* offered by UCLA.

rocker

2/4/17 12:45pm

That is a cool list. Thanks for putting it togethet.

Stucoug83

2/4/17 1:02pm

This is cool but I wonder what transfers to other schools is like

SouthernBlueBlood

2/4/17 1:23pm

Other offers are a better gauge than "stars"

cougarnw

2/4/17 1:27pm

Nice! Thanks for putting this together. Only goes to show that it is

mellomike

2/4/17 1:54pm

Can't count RMs

2/5/17 2:15pm

He didn't count guys going out.

southernfriedcougar

2/5/17 2:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad