49ers made it to the SB with CK and then back to the NFC champ game the next year. Wasn't the wrong decision at the time

Sep 18, 2018
11:52:17am

scootsy First name: Tom; Last: Foolery

Report problem with this ad

scootsy

Bio page: scootsy
Joined: Aug 5, 2013
Last login: Jun 8, 2024
Total posts: 30,810 (3,418 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I am a Chiefs fan. And I am an Alex Smith fan...

Tokolosh

9/18/18 11:46am

Unpopular opinion

Randall Toomey

9/18/18 11:51am

High floor, low ceiling. Id say above average. there are a lot of bad qbs out there

Deleted

9/18/18 11:54am

He has been with a decimated roster before.

Tokolosh

9/18/18 11:55am

Who and when?

Randall Toomey

9/18/18 11:58am

Yes, and he was benched several times and booed off the field. We

messi

9/18/18 12:47pm

Very few QBs would look any different in the same circumstances.

Tokolosh

9/18/18 12:52pm

Kaepernick played better with a worse supporting cast.

messi

9/18/18 12:54pm

CK did what the Niners were already poised to do...

Tokolosh

9/18/18 1:01pm

But he couldn’t make big plays. He wasn’t explosive. And Smith was 6-2 with

messi

9/18/18 1:09pm

He got to that game with a game winning TD pass with 9 seconds left.

Tokolosh

9/18/18 1:15pm

And then was terrible in the more important game.

messi

9/18/18 1:37pm

TNT is in the overrated camp

TNT

9/18/18 12:21pm

49ers made it to the SB with CK and then back to the NFC champ game the next year. Wasn't the wrong decision at the time

scootsy

9/18/18 11:52am

They made it to the Super Bowl with half a season from Smith...

Tokolosh

9/18/18 12:02pm

Starting Mahomes is a no brainer. There's been a lot of great QB's drafted the

Josef K

9/18/18 12:00pm

I'll take Wentz

kimdaddy35

9/18/18 12:09pm

I like Mahomes, Wentz and Goff

Josef K

9/18/18 12:15pm

Mahomes has played 2 games so far, so I'm not sure how you already know

kimdaddy35

9/18/18 12:26pm

Well, I didn't say he was the best based on this year alone

Josef K

9/18/18 12:42pm

The playoff comparison is not exactly fair

kimdaddy35

9/18/18 1:06pm

I've always liked Alex Smith. His only character flaw is that he went to

CougBlu

9/18/18 1:44pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad