My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 26, 2019
5:34
:15
pm
Cougarpride
All-American
I don’t place a season’s success based on one game!
10 - 2 regardless who the two losses were against, would be successful!!
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Cougarpride
Bio page
Cougarpride
Joined
Feb 19, 2003
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
5,269 (1,054 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: If you had to pick between BYU finishing 10-2 with a loss to Utah but end ranked between 20-25, or Finish 7-5 with a win over Utah and unranked?
bigbossbyu
5/25/19 10:44pm
It’s hard, if there wasn’t such a long streak going
cougarfann888
5/25/19 10:53pm
I think a 10-win season despite a loss to Utah would do better for both
ataylor
5/25/19 11:45pm
I wouldn’t trade more than one win vs any team over a single win vs Utah
Jericho
5/25/19 11:02pm
Sorry but I’m not trading 3 wins for a Utah win. That’s both sad and pathetic
Indy Coug
5/25/19 11:18pm
It’s trading 4 other wins for a win over Utah. Crazy talk.
garyfan
5/26/19 12:56am
Very true
cajuncoug
5/26/19 12:12pm
You’re definitely not from Utah then.
BountifulCoug5
5/26/19 9:13pm
I was born in Utah and lived there for 15 years
Indy Coug
5/26/19 10:50pm
10-2 being ranked in the 20-25 range means we didn’t win a meaningful game.
Blue Cat
5/25/19 11:32pm
Being 10-2 means we won 10 meaningful games
MaxxPower
5/26/19 12:00am
Complaining about beating USC, Tennessee, and Boise State is silly
BrutustheBrash
5/26/19 12:10am
Except I wasn’t complaining.
Blue Cat
5/26/19 12:18am
Ok so you’re downplaying it, maybe not complaining
BrutustheBrash
5/26/19 12:45am
<< Deleted >>
Blue Cat
5/26/19 12:50am
We are in a bad spot if we think beating 3 to 4 win P5s is a big deal.
Blue Cat
5/26/19 12:56am
USC is a blueblood and Tennessee is the next tier
BrutustheBrash
5/26/19 8:51am
I guess the point is 10-2 gets you much better than ranked 20-25, unless our
viper
5/26/19 12:41pm
In the 10-2 situation does Utah finish ranked higher than us or are they 7-5
BlueBlitzkrieg
5/26/19 11:00am
Meant for OP
BlueBlitzkrieg
5/26/19 11:01am
There would be a meaningful win
puntersarepeople
5/26/19 8:12am
No it doesn’t.
jkccoug
5/26/19 5:58pm
Going 10-2 with a loss to Utah means BYU goes 2-1 against USC, UW, and Tennessee
ataylor
5/25/19 11:46pm
At least 2-1, rather. Could mean beating all three of those teams and losing to
ataylor
5/25/19 11:47pm
That means 2-1 against Tennessee, USC and Washington. I'll take it
paulb
5/25/19 11:59pm
Good point.
ataylor
5/26/19 12:03am
If BYU is 10-2 we'd better be ranked higher than #20. BYU ain't UCF. Pollsters
UberDeek
5/26/19 12:08am
That was my thought. 10-2 would put us in the 12-15 range. It would take some
dratax
5/26/19 12:16am
We absolutely could be ranked in this range
Blue Cat
5/26/19 12:31am
Well, I'm not a uofu fan, so I don't automatically believe all of our opponents
UberDeek
5/26/19 12:34am
Wow. Strange response. Who mentioned anything about belief?
Blue Cat
5/26/19 12:47am
You pointed out a schedule where we only beat one team with a winning record
UberDeek
5/26/19 1:13am
He's saying that if BYU goes 10-2 and is still only ranked in the 20-25 range,
kos
5/26/19 5:06am
It's very unlikely. 10-11 win G5 teams finish 20-25 and they have much
Lip Gallagher
5/26/19 12:43pm
Idk how the CFP poll responds to BYU
BrutustheBrash
5/26/19 12:40am
Owned by ESPN
UberDeek
5/26/19 1:13am
No hesitation from me
schofim
5/26/19 12:57am
I might agree EXCEPT for the fact they’ve beat us 9 straight. That’s embarrassin
ByuImaginesDragons
5/26/19 2:47am
Also you don’t live here and have to face Utah fans every day. I want to shut
ByuImaginesDragons
5/26/19 2:48am
Two comments
schofim
5/26/19 4:33am
Wins over Utah >>>> everything else. Id take 5-7 if we beat Utah
Dissenter
5/26/19 8:01am
This is why all of us local fans care so much about the Utah game.
BountifulCoug5
5/26/19 9:13pm
I just can’t stomach another Utah loss under any circumstance
ByuImaginesDragons
5/26/19 2:42am
I've moved on. Would rather have the 10 win season, which against this schedule
HighHorse
5/26/19 5:04am
Wow some of you have reverse little brother complex. This is truly ridiculous.
BeefNoodleSoup
5/26/19 5:33am
I was going to choose option #1, but since #2 is more likely I chose reality
BeardedSpock
5/26/19 7:18am
such sad results
BlueFrog
5/26/19 8:15am
Is it though? Beating Utah should be #1 priority over everything
Dissenter
5/26/19 8:57am
RE: Is it though? Beating Utah should be #1 priority over everything
BlueBlitzkrieg
5/26/19 11:03am
Have to beat Utah and reestablish local dominance.
rad dawg
5/26/19 9:27am
Getting one win in almost a decade doesn't "reestablish" anything.
Lip Gallagher
5/26/19 12:47pm
Definitely helps with recruiting though
BountifulCoug5
5/26/19 9:21pm
Not any more than a 10 win season
puntersarepeople
5/26/19 9:24pm
Definitely? No, not definitely. More like tiny possibility but mostly no.
Lip Gallagher
5/26/19 10:05pm
Lol, ok.
BountifulCoug5
5/27/19 8:24am
Keep telling yourself it does.
Lip Gallagher
5/27/19 9:08am
10-2
Sale
5/26/19 10:42am
&-5 and break the streak. Then go undefeated next year.
Florwood
5/26/19 11:49am
Finishing a season ranked will help our program a lot more than one win vs Utah
puntersarepeople
5/26/19 12:21pm
Utes would take the 10 two and lose to BYU. That would mean Rose Bowl.
brejol
5/26/19 1:13pm
And for BYU it would mean the Hawaii bowl
cougarfann888
5/26/19 1:19pm
It would depend on other conferences, and how well Utah does. 10-2 would give
Lance71
5/26/19 1:41pm
PAC12 doesn’t deserve a BCS bowl appearance
puntersarepeople
5/26/19 1:53pm
10-2.
Yoopercoug
5/26/19 2:39pm
I don’t place a season’s success based on one game!
Cougarpride
5/26/19 5:34pm
Break this down by geography. Everyone who works with or lives by a Ute is
Ash
5/26/19 6:25pm
Not true
schofim
5/26/19 6:38pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad