Bob Waterfield who played from 1945-52

Report problem with this ad

Jul 8, 2020
4:49:32pm

donnerstag All-American

Bob Waterfield who played from 1945-52

10 seasons seems to be the minimum in the modern era

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Jun 2, 2024
Total posts: 39,181 (684 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Is Patrick Mahomes already Hall of Fame worthy?

BYUfan92

7/8/20 1:47pm

Oh, please. You can’t be serious

Lifi

7/8/20 1:49pm

I didn’t think so either, that’s why the ESPN guys comments floored me...

BYUfan92

7/8/20 1:57pm

ESPN....there you go. They are the new MSNBC. Garbage Network

Lifi

7/8/20 2:16pm

If he was hit by a bus tomorrow he'd go into the hall of fame.

shimmy

7/8/20 1:49pm

Would he if he said, "I'm tired of football" and quit tomorrow?

gwalker

7/8/20 1:50pm

No

shimmy

7/8/20 1:50pm

That's stupid. You can't play 2 or 3 years and make the hall of fame.

Duke Silver

7/8/20 1:50pm

Depends on why they stop playing

MormonThug

7/8/20 1:54pm

Was Mark Rypien after his SB MVP performance? Lots of QBs had amazing runs for a year or 2. Very few with a decade+

7/8/20 1:51pm

Joe Flacco

Busiturtle

7/8/20 1:55pm

HOF caliber and HOF worthy are 2 different things. He's HOF caliber for sure

SlantRoute

7/8/20 1:53pm

Not ridiculous but definitely premature. NFL MVP, SB MVP, has set some new records. But yes need 5+yrs.

Grit for Brains

7/8/20 1:59pm

Poll needs to read

Bin01015

7/8/20 1:53pm

The shortest career QB in the Hall of Fame is 8 seasons

donnerstag

7/8/20 1:59pm

Who was it that made the HOF after only 8 playing years?

BYUfan92

7/8/20 3:07pm

Bob Waterfield who played from 1945-52

donnerstag

7/8/20 4:49pm

Honestly I've never heard of him. Thanks for the info, I'll look him up a bit

BYUfan92

7/8/20 5:54pm

He'll be the GOAT if he puts in another 12 years similar to the last 2.

CougarHut

7/8/20 2:11pm

Not yet.

HighHorse

7/8/20 2:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad