This made me laugh, but it is also true.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Aug 2, 2021
9:58:29am

crack Truly Addicted User

This made me laugh, but it is also true.

Report problem with this ad

crack

Bio page: crack
Joined: Nov 17, 2005
Last login: Jun 4, 2024
Total posts: 42,557 (120 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Songs where the cover was better than the original.

Revolution

8/2/21 9:46am

Hurt by Johnny Cash has to be #1

crack

8/2/21 9:47am

It's Johnny Cash's best song

Hotlanta

8/2/21 9:54am

I agree it’s a good cover, but NIN original is still better. More pain in Reznor’s voice.

specsauce

8/2/21 10:17am

NIN's is manic-depressive, Cash's is regretful

Hotlanta

8/2/21 10:23am

Yes, they are both great in their own way as they are conveying different messages.

El Careeb

8/2/21 10:29am

I agree with much of your list save Faith. That version is pure garbage.

gangbusters

8/2/21 9:48am

All along the watchtower. Knocking on heavens door.

Backcountry

8/2/21 9:48am

All Along the Watchtower.

bluesloth

8/2/21 9:49am

Sound of Silence by Disturbed is basically the U of U of covers. It praised by low class uneducated chest thumpers

IceBlueCoug

8/2/21 9:49am

And my daughter… jerk

Revolution

8/2/21 9:49am

This needs to added to the list in it's place

IceBlueCoug

8/2/21 9:50am

Strong ADDITION to the list

Revolution

8/2/21 9:51am

But honestly, is your OP a reverse?? Because it sure seems like it should be.

pink22

8/2/21 9:52am

It is not a reverse.

Revolution

8/2/21 9:54am

Its trash

Backcountry

8/2/21 10:04am

Don't consider myself a chest thumper, definitely not uneducated

NYC and Japan

8/2/21 10:54am

ok ryan

MormonThug

8/2/21 11:53am

<< Deleted >>

TerpCoug

8/2/21 12:46pm

Its been evaluated by music experts who disagree with your assessment..

8/3/21 10:21am

Definitely not Sound of Silence by Disturbed

yerromnitsuj

8/2/21 9:49am

Dynamite Hack Boyz in the Hood

BigYfan

8/2/21 9:50am

So good

Backcountry

8/2/21 10:05am

In the same vein...Today was a Good Day is great as well.

8/2/21 10:15am

Blinded By the Light by Manfred Mann

bluecheese

8/2/21 9:50am

Landslide by Smashing Pumpkins. Maybe nobody agrees with me. I don't care.

8/2/21 9:50am

That’s an amazing cover, Billy’s voice is way better and his guitar solo has so

Penske Material

8/2/21 11:15am

<< Deleted >>

8/2/21 12:27pm

If you think Faith by Limp Bizkit is better than Faith by George Michael, you

pink22

8/2/21 9:51am

I just listened to faith by limp bizkit on youtube. Yikes. I actually didn't

8/2/21 9:54am

I mean if there was never an original version written of it that is great then

pink22

8/2/21 10:11am

Fair point.

8/2/21 10:13am

I like the Limp Bizkit version better

dragekoz

8/2/21 10:30am

The Smiths are close to the greatest band ever and most certainly the most

pink22

8/2/21 10:55am

Nothing Compares 2 U

Tortoise

8/2/21 9:51am

I was thinking about this. It's just very different

Beggar

8/2/21 9:51am

I didn't realize that was a Prince song until just now. I agree with you, but I

8/2/21 9:56am

This is a good version too

TrackCoug

8/2/21 10:01am

I prefer Chris' solo version...don't know why but it just grows on you

NOCAL_YFAN

8/2/21 10:05am

Definitely

inertiaman

8/2/21 10:09am

I Will Survive - Cake.

bluesloth

8/2/21 9:51am

H-yes

m0resn0w

8/2/21 10:12am

I Will Always Love You - Whitney Houston

Odysseus

8/2/21 9:51am

RE: I Will Always Love You - Whitney Houston

aemadrid

8/2/21 1:48pm

Sound of Silence is a great cover, but its not better than the original

Hotlanta

8/2/21 9:53am

Turn the Page by Metallica was my first thought.

mncougar

8/2/21 9:53am

Besame Mucho by Diane Schuur and Maynard Ferguson

backprop

8/2/21 9:53am

Hazy Shade of Winter: Bangles

Jimo Dashen

8/2/21 9:53am

This made me laugh, but it is also true.

crack

8/2/21 9:58am

RE: Hazy Shade of Winter: Bangles

aemadrid

8/2/21 1:49pm

I personally like Behind Blue Eyes by Limp Bizkit over The Who

Adwight

8/2/21 9:53am

Zombie: Bad Wolves (probably an unpopular choice but 🤷‍♂️)

Jimo Dashen

8/2/21 9:55am

1 more. Heartless: Kris Allen

Jimo Dashen

8/2/21 9:58am

Dude, Limp Bizkit?

Jay Kay

8/2/21 9:58am

One Sweet Day

Fishious

8/2/21 9:59am

Poncho and Lefty by Willie and Haggard

Corn

8/2/21 9:59am

Good cover, but I like the Emmylou Harris cover even more.

UCLACoug

8/2/21 12:58pm

Adding “Sway” by Diana Krall

Revolution

8/2/21 9:59am

I'll probably get crucified for saying this but Jeff Buckley's Hallelujah and

byujacob

8/2/21 9:59am

I think everyone agrees that hallelujah covers are better than the original, and

Jay Rick

8/2/21 10:05am

I meant more for the cover of The Boxer.

byujacob

8/2/21 10:36am

With a Little Help from My Friends by Joe Coker

byujacob

8/2/21 10:00am

Does Walk this Way by Run DMC count?

crack

8/2/21 10:01am

RE: Does Walk this Way by Run DMC count?

byujacob

8/2/21 10:02am

Landslide, The Chicks.

Traveshamockery

8/2/21 10:02am

Talk about a group that ruined their career by getting involved in Politics.

crack

8/2/21 10:05am

and Toby Keith's only got bigger by getting involved in that mess

8/2/21 10:20am

Cancel cancel culture!

joelvandyne

8/2/21 10:53am

Gotta know your audience. Country music and wokeness do not coexist.

Big Daddy D

8/2/21 3:01pm

Original is at least 10 times better

BigYfan

8/2/21 10:06am

I just like this version better. The original seems slower and boring to me.

Traveshamockery

8/2/21 11:37am

Landslide by the Pumpkins

CrashMcLarson

8/2/21 10:07am

Maybe if this were a post about the worst of the popular versions of classic

Jay Kay

8/2/21 10:15am

Some people like different music and version. Crazy.

Traveshamockery

8/2/21 11:32am

I think that musically the Chicks song is fine. What bothers me about it is that

Jay Kay

8/2/21 12:08pm

You’ve put much more thought into this than me.

Traveshamockery

8/2/21 12:59pm

Did you not get the memo? The word Dixie has been deemed racist. Just “Chicks”

Corn Pop

8/2/21 10:19am

Fixed

Traveshamockery

8/2/21 11:35am

Back in the Saddle by Aerosmith

sanitarium

8/2/21 10:02am

Didn’t we just have this conversation like 3 days ago? Anyway, Walk This Way, as

Jay Rick

8/2/21 10:04am

If we did, I missed it.

Revolution

8/2/21 10:08am

You can’t possibly be blamed for that. Just funny that we’re covering all the

Jay Rick

8/2/21 10:28am

THe Man Who Sold The World (Nirvana)

Avery

8/2/21 10:05am

True. I hate Bowie and Nirvana, but that cover is awesome.

Penske Material

8/2/21 11:13am

Joe Cocker--With a Little Help From My Friends, Knockin on Hevans Door--GnR

Jay Kay

8/2/21 10:06am

Losing My Religion by Lacuna Coil

Jacare

8/2/21 10:06am

That is a terrible version of the song!

TrackCoug

8/2/21 12:47pm

🤣🤣🤣

Jacare

8/2/21 2:24pm

Romeo and Juliet-The Killers

BE-WHY-YOU

8/2/21 10:07am

It's fine. The original is amazing. It reminds me of Weezer's cover of Africa.

8/2/21 10:12am

If you never heard Knopfler play guitar, you could see the

bald man

8/2/21 10:55am

This one has always been my favorite. Eruption/You Really Got Me - Van Halen

Belboz

8/2/21 10:12am

Foo Fighters singing Never Going to Give You Up in their style with Rick Astley

crack

8/2/21 10:16am

That is pretty cool

8/2/21 10:20am

Flame away if you must but I really like Cold Play's cover of 'Til Kingdom Come'

m0resn0w

8/2/21 10:17am

Who is this supposedly a cover of?

8/3/21 7:04am

Huh...now that you mention it. Turns out that it was written for Johnny Cash,

m0resn0w

8/4/21 1:32pm

Every single song where someone covered Bob Dylan.

valleus

8/2/21 10:24am

True!

sanitarium

8/2/21 10:26am

Its true

Backcountry

8/2/21 10:43am

well that's a safe bet.

Belboz

8/2/21 5:34pm

George Michael's version of I Can't Make You Love Me

Kelbob

8/2/21 10:25am

Can't Help Falling in Love - nearly everyone not named Elvis.

Eddie

8/2/21 10:26am

Absolutely nothing by Limp Bizkit is better than just turning off the radio

spinner

8/2/21 10:27am

Last Kiss done by Pearl Jam

Kelbob

8/2/21 10:27am

Tennessee Whiskey - Chris Stapleton

8/2/21 10:28am

I know someone who slays the cover of Tennessee Whiskey

ByuImaginesDragons

8/3/21 12:55am

Do you have a name?

8/3/21 1:27am

DANGIT!! I forgot the link 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️ It’s by Jay Warren (added link)

ByuImaginesDragons

8/3/21 1:43am

JTM's buddy. That's a great version. Thanks for sharing

8/3/21 10:14am

Yep. Both very talented men

ByuImaginesDragons

8/3/21 10:00pm

Also this cover of a Post Malone song shows his talent off much better…

ByuImaginesDragons

8/3/21 2:01am

Jeff Buckley's Hallelujah

Tominator

8/2/21 10:31am

Soft Cell's Tainted Love

El Careeb

8/2/21 10:32am

(I can’t get no) Satisfaction by Devo

spinner

8/2/21 10:36am

Mayday - Home Free . . . the original is nothing compared to HF's version

8/2/21 10:37am

Santeria by Zergabachew on The Voice is really good

8/2/21 10:39am

The mere suggestion that Metallica topped Seger should get this post deleted.

Richard McCoy Jr.

8/2/21 10:51am

Black Magic Woman - Santana (Fleetwood Mac = Original and is also really good).

BYU1982

8/2/21 10:57am

Hall and Oates: You've lost that lovin' feelin'. Much better than Righteous Bros

lawilson

8/2/21 11:00am

You Really Got Me - Van Halen

Peter Venkman

8/2/21 11:13am

Trigger warning: Heart Stairway to heaven w Zeppelin’s original drummer’s son

kotacoug

8/2/21 11:22am

That seemed to be a remake more than a cover.

Elwood Blues

8/2/21 11:41am

Sounds of Silence by Disturbed! I believe we've covered this before.

TeeKaa

8/2/21 11:38am

"Big Yellow Taxi" by Counting Crows. "I Can See Clearly Now" by Jimmy Cliff

Brigham

8/2/21 11:59am

Blitzkrieg by Metallica

8/2/21 12:28pm

Here are a few that might qualify

DJROSS

8/2/21 12:37pm

CCR's version of I Heard it Through the Grapevine is also good

StickyBumps

8/3/21 9:20am

Maybe something by Me First and The Gimme Gimmes

Beest

8/2/21 2:13pm

Disagree with Turn The Page...Seger's is much better IMO.

socorny

8/2/21 5:28pm

plus 1,000

TeeKaa

8/2/21 5:45pm

I Can't Explain by The Scorpions

socorny

8/2/21 5:31pm

This, mostly because the original is so bad.

Penske Material

8/2/21 6:32pm

Up Around the Bend - Hanoi Rocks

bluecheese

8/3/21 11:19am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad