Not really. But it almost always does. Just like the second “late hit out of bounds” penalty last week.

Sep 19, 2021
11:19:07am

mvtoro Scrub

Would never be called if it was a running back. Still shouldnt have been called in my opinion, but much more likely on a QB.

Report problem with this ad

mvtoro

Bio page: mvtoro
Joined: Nov 28, 2006
Last login: Jun 7, 2024
Total posts: 11,847 (763 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Watching the replay in slow motion and the ASU guy performs a perfect example

idcougarfan

9/19/21 10:52am

^^^This

Cougs or die

9/19/21 10:53am

That's why the crowd was booing so loud.

byuluvr

9/19/21 10:53am

Hall knew it immediately and asked the refs to look at it. I don’t understand

Star-Lord

9/19/21 10:55am

Hard to get that call on a runner. If the same hit was on a RB nobody thinks

FrontLineFan

9/19/21 10:58am

Not saying I agree with targeting, but that was targeting.

idcougarfan

9/19/21 10:59am

But not the kind that is called/penalized very often.

FrontLineFan

9/19/21 11:00am

It’s for sure a conflicting part of the game. Happens at the LOS every play.

DiamondMo

9/19/21 11:03am

It’s the QB and was behind the LOS should that

kotacoug

9/19/21 11:13am

Not really. But it almost always does. Just like the second “late hit out of bounds” penalty last week.

mvtoro

9/19/21 11:19am

If you’re referring to the play I think you are, I don’t think Hall was a

Dave Matthew

9/19/21 10:59am

Using the crown (or top) of your helmet to tackle is targeting regardless of whether ball carrier is “defenseless” or

mvtoro

9/19/21 11:02am

In the open field, yes. In a scrum?

Dave Matthew

9/19/21 11:05am

BYU fans extra concerned because it was our QB & he's had concussion issues.

FrontLineFan

9/19/21 11:09am

I don’t think they were in a scrum; I think it was one-on-one in the backfield. But regardless, what I was addressing is

mvtoro

9/19/21 11:17am

I think we’re in agreement, more or less.

Dave Matthew

9/19/21 11:29am

100%. One of my biggest frustrations watching a game in the stands (maybe the only one really) is fans booing because

mvtoro

9/19/21 11:39am

Though it was horrible tackling technique. Absolutely terrible. Face up always.

kotacoug

9/19/21 1:47pm

That’s why that’s part of the criteria for targeting.

Powerbait DPM

9/19/21 2:37pm

Defenseless player? Not at all. It was a designed QB draw, he had become a RB

stoils

9/19/21 4:39pm

Yeah, not a defenseless player. But tackler still launched and led with crown

Powerbait DPM

9/19/21 8:25pm

Hall just needed to lay still for a moment & act hurt & they would’ve called it.

RUNBYU1

9/19/21 12:50pm

He ain’t no soccer player though

ByuImaginesDragons

9/19/21 1:36pm

TBH, we had a hit I thought could have been called targeting in the 4th. They

DescendentCoug

9/19/21 12:58pm

which play? I thought there were possibly two times he was targeted.

here's to hoping

9/19/21 1:19pm

The way he lowered his head to hit, I thought they should have called it to

tony

9/19/21 1:22pm

I felt like Hall could have sold it a bit more, but somewhat glad he didn't take the soccer approach.

Posting on CougarBoard