A hypothetical. Let’s say a runner beats Bolt’s world record and has an incredib

May 20, 2022
5:46:55pm

Sparkling Delirium Starter

Run for a couple of years. Wins only one gold, and doesn’t match or surpass Bolt’s totals. Who is the goat? The one with the world record or the one who had the most medals?

Report problem with this ad

Sparkling Delirium

Bio page: Sparkling Delirium
Joined: May 7, 2015
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 6,031 (18 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: GOAT - Jack or Tiger?

Pollster Starter

5/20/22 5:14pm

Jack’s record is still better

JOPE

5/20/22 5:16pm

And for me that gives Tiger the edge b/c his prime was so long and so dominant.

garyfan

5/20/22 5:18pm

I'm torn. Is 73 wins and 18 majors better than 82 and 15? Probably. Jack finished 2nd or 3rd 27 times in majors!

Pollster

5/20/22 5:20pm

I don’t think you can fail at your one most important stated goal and be the 🐐

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 5:20pm

I could care less who the golf GOAT is, but that’s a dumb qualifier.

DieHarder

5/20/22 5:21pm

I’m deeply offended. But, I’ll engage. If you set out to accomplish something,

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 5:23pm

Id guess they both had a goals to win every tournament they played in. Losers!

DiamondMo

5/20/22 5:32pm

I see you agree with me. That’s great.

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 5:38pm

I didn’t say what you said. Do we still agree on the things we said?

DiamondMo

5/20/22 6:27pm

RE: I didn’t say what you said. Do we still agree on the things we said?

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 6:47pm

I disagree

DiamondMo

5/20/22 6:49pm

RE: I disagree

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 6:52pm

A hypothetical. Let’s say a runner beats Bolt’s world record and has an incredib

Sparkling Delirium

5/20/22 5:46pm

What if someone got 29 gold medals but he always talked about how he wanted 30. Disqualified from the GOAT convo?

DieHarder

5/20/22 5:53pm

His point is that someone else actually got 30.

garyfan

5/20/22 5:56pm

Yeah, and that’s a good reason for that guy to be the GOAT.

DieHarder

5/20/22 6:13pm

It’s hard to compare because Jack never had to compete against Justin Leonard.

garyfan

5/20/22 5:47pm

Right. no fair. He only had Arnold Palmer, Gary Player, Billy Casper.... these guys were all horrible.

crimedog

5/20/22 5:51pm

Ok, Leonard and Cink.

garyfan

5/20/22 5:56pm

Real Golfers hate Tiger.....

crimedog

5/20/22 5:26pm

Almost got triggered... then I realized this is now a Shaun White thread.

Gunga Galunga

5/20/22 6:11pm

hehe

crimedog

5/20/22 6:36pm

RE: Real Golfers hate Tiger.....

Emmett Fitz-Hume

5/20/22 6:58pm

How many golf courses were adjusted to make them “Jack” proof?

Big12Yfan

5/20/22 5:30pm

Depth of competition that Jack competed against isn’t comparable to Tiger. It’s

Posting on CougarBoard