Jamaal had more yards and a higher ypc. He also has had a better NFL career. I personally would put him

Aug 15, 2022
3:52:41pm

kimdaddy35 Future Lions Scout

just slightly ahead of Harvey. But if Harvey has his Senior season he is likely #1 on this list (although quite a few of our good backs missed a year).

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Jun 7, 2024
Total posts: 47,047 (1,486 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Continuing on, a deep dive into the best RBs of all-time at BYU

kimdaddy35 Future Lions Scout

8/15/22 3:44pm

Swap 2 and 3. But good list.

Backcountry

8/15/22 3:47pm

Jamaal had more yards and a higher ypc. He also has had a better NFL career. I personally would put him

kimdaddy35

8/15/22 3:52pm

Agree

Blueto

8/15/22 3:49pm

RE: Continuing on, a deep dive into the best RBs of all-time at BYU

porl thompson

8/15/22 3:56pm

Excellent summary of RBs through the years.

kccougar

8/15/22 3:58pm

Thank you, I did my best. Obviously the rankings are very subjective with the given information.

kimdaddy35

8/15/22 4:04pm

Memory serves that all three were 'gold' when it came to game-winning,

BlueInfidel

8/16/22 4:10am

Good list. Follow up question:

Huge Manatee

8/15/22 4:11pm

That is a great question. It depends on a number of factors, but I think I choose Allgeier over Unga, Williams

kimdaddy35

8/15/22 4:22pm

If fully healthy…Ty’Son Williams. Most talented pound for pound running back

Posting on CougarBoard