We've only had poor ones since, sans year1

Report problem with this ad

Oct 5, 2022
2:54:47pm

CarolinaCoug Intervention Needed

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 5, 2022 at 2:54:47pm

Message modified by CarolinaCoug on Oct 5, 2022 at 3:04:21pm

Message modified by CarolinaCoug on Oct 5, 2022 at 3:04:38pm

Report problem with this ad

CarolinaCoug

Bio page: CarolinaCoug
Joined: Dec 9, 2002
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 60,612 (3,191 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I miss Bronco’s defenses:

mulletino mulletYno@gmail

10/5/22 2:48pm

I miss Brady Poppinga

Blueto

10/5/22 2:50pm

I think Wilgar has some Poppinga traits. But tough to make big plays sitting back and taking on guards every play.

kimdaddy35

10/5/22 3:41pm

Bronco had some awesome defenses. And some really poor ones.

shoganai

10/5/22 2:51pm

We've only had poor ones since, sans year1

CarolinaCoug

10/5/22 2:54pm

Only 2 were average or below since 2007 and none nearly as bad as last year.

ManicBlue

10/5/22 2:57pm

Depends which set of analytics you look at.

shoganai

10/5/22 3:03pm

And 2 of Crowton’s terrible defenses were with Bronco as the DC

icecougar

10/5/22 3:09pm

Lol. You think BYU’s defenses in both 2003 and 2004 were bad?

mulletino

10/5/22 3:10pm

They were both average or a little below, statistically. But a big improvement

shoganai

10/5/22 3:48pm

Naturally, after Crowton signed all those players in 2004 that got thrown out, left, and/or ultimately murdered people

mulletino

10/5/22 4:36pm

Bronco was a very average recruiter, but his talent tended to over-perform its

shoganai

10/5/22 5:02pm

You mean the defensive players that Bronco helped recruit and failed to control?

icecougar

10/8/22 2:56am

Prove it. Bronco is the biggest disciplinarian BYU's has ever employed.

mulletino

10/8/22 8:04am

Bronco's discipline may have saved BYU football. BYU football couldn't take any more problems at that time.

ManicBlue

10/8/22 10:22am

So he had 2 bad defenses in 13 seasons as HC/DC?

mulletino

10/5/22 3:10pm

Not compared to tuiaki both were better than tuiakis

CarolinaCoug

10/5/22 3:11pm

Ag&$&(:.

mulletino

10/5/22 3:12pm

2014 wasn’t good either

icecougar

10/8/22 2:57am

The year BYU would have gone undefeated if not for Taysom's injury? yeah, that year.

mulletino

10/8/22 8:04am

I like fei. Accordong to their analytics '05& 14 wer better than Tuiakis 72 in17

CarolinaCoug

10/5/22 3:10pm

2005 is pretty understandable given the Crowton yrs and the number of recruiting misses.

ManicBlue

10/5/22 3:12pm

If you're arguing that Bronco is a better defensive coach than Tuiaki, you won't

shoganai

10/5/22 3:46pm

Problem is that we need one as good as Bronco going forward.. With P5 money, recruiting and

ManicBlue

10/5/22 3:51pm

If someone as good as Bronco is the requirement, we are hopeless.

shoganai

10/5/22 3:53pm

I'm fine if they don't stay long term. Teach the defensive assistants we have to take over.

ManicBlue

10/5/22 4:30pm

Sounds like you've got it all figured out.

shoganai

10/5/22 4:35pm

Wishful thinking. However, I wouldn't mind these guys either.

ManicBlue

10/5/22 4:42pm

I'm sure they'd be strong candidates if there was a job opening at BYU.

shoganai

10/5/22 4:59pm

Never say never. 😉

ManicBlue

10/5/22 5:02pm

I can see why you used the 2004 highlights and not the 2005 game.

Indy Coug

10/5/22 2:57pm

The BYU 3-3-5 experiment ended poorly, but the 3-4 went well for the most part.

Corn Pop

10/5/22 3:02pm

Actually it was just what popped up on my Instagram feed. But yeah, Bronco didn’t have much to work with in 2005.

mulletino

10/5/22 3:09pm

Bronco made me excited about the defense for the 1st time

BigHouse Coug

10/5/22 2:59pm

2012 season was a fun D

icecougar

10/5/22 3:10pm

Was that the year of the Kyle Van Noy Bowl?

BigHouse Coug

10/5/22 3:25pm

Wait. People can touch the quarterback?

My Fingers Hurt

10/5/22 3:02pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

10/5/22 3:05pm

Hes trying to make d1 qbs have anxiety attacks and fold by patience

CarolinaCoug

10/5/22 3:13pm

Can't decide whether to give this post a happy or sad face...

WhyaskY?

10/5/22 7:42pm

I miss the sideline lineup and count then run onto the field thing.

monteburns

10/5/22 3:15pm

The fact that fans have a problem with that is really funny

kimdaddy35

10/5/22 3:40pm

2012 was incredible

Backcountry

10/5/22 4:00pm

This is why ND won't come to BYU.

Benfica1

10/5/22 4:14pm

People forget his defenses gave up a lot of points at times. They did have some

Thrill

10/5/22 4:57pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

10/5/22 5:58pm

Um, TOP is a bad comparison. POINTS are actually what matters.

Benfica1

10/5/22 7:44pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

10/5/22 9:51pm

Whew, I was worried about ya.

Benfica1

10/5/22 11:06pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

10/6/22 4:27am

Here are some while he was DC before getting others involved coordinating

Thrill

10/5/22 11:49pm

He was the DC and HC from 2006-2009. And other years.

mulletino

10/5/22 11:57pm

Had to go all the way back to when he first arrived to help Crowton with his dumpster fire? hahaha

ManicBlue

10/6/22 12:00am

Here are the average defensive pts/game.

ManicBlue

10/5/22 11:11pm

Quite comparable

NYC and Japan

10/5/22 11:57pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

10/6/22 4:28am

Not those uniforms tho...yeesh

reppintheY14

10/5/22 7:00pm

Bronco had some great defenses. But the competition was not the same as what we have faced this year and last.

Posting on CougarBoard