I won't use any other shovels. It has a wide scoop and it's designed to be easy to push. Anyone that says the one you posted isn't any good obviously doesn't know what they're talking about. My whole neighborhood uses them now. They're great for wives too since they can push the U shaped bar using both arms. The ones with 1 straight handle are harder to push and you can't be symmetrical when pushing, which wears out your muscles faster.