What is it Loyal BYU? This anonymous editor doesn't know squat. What is your coaching experience. I coached football 12 years up to varsity level. I wiil say this: your top line athletes don't want a position given to them, they want to earn it. They don't want to play behind someone who has played substandard football for 4 or five games either. NFL QBs get a little bit longer rope. Several posters have convinced me of the critical mass point that BYU is at now, play the producing player. Pro Tanner point, Tanner wasn't close to 100%. That we don't want to lose a redshirt year Press release stuff turned out to be turned out to be just that although the post game release was masterfully written