I'd probably break it down by offense/defense

May 18, 2019
4:58:47pm

donnerstag All-American

Offense
1) Bushman
2) Empey
3) Wilson
4) Romney
5) T.Williams
6) Hifo
7) Christensen

Defense
1) Dayan
2) Tonga
3) Zayne
4) I. Kaufusi
5) Mandell
6) Lee
7) Fauatea

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: May 17, 2024
Total posts: 39,082 (684 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Top ten players on this years team in order

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 2:54pm

<< Deleted >>

HarlemCoug

5/18/19 2:58pm

ZW is Zach Wilson

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 2:58pm

Do you mean overall potential? Or impact this year? If it's impact this year,

Rise Against

5/18/19 3:01pm

How good they are at their position

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 3:07pm

He's most likely going to redshirt this year and then hopefully be healthy

Rise Against

5/18/19 3:08pm

That’s unfortunate. Greene needs to show out then

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 3:20pm

I think Greene and Herron will step up and fill that #2 CB spot w/ Mandell at 1.

Rise Against

5/18/19 3:22pm

I’d put Austin Lee in the top 10 over Katoa and Fauatea honorable mention

Coop

5/18/19 3:09pm

I knew was forgetting someone

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 3:21pm

I didn't realize Austin Lee still had eligibility. Thought he graduated for some reason.

SingleStrapBackpack

5/18/19 3:28pm

If Greene and Herron can step up and earn the coaches trust, then Dayan can

Rise Against

5/18/19 3:33pm

If you rewatch the Boise game

I'mBatman

5/18/19 3:13pm

I think it's literally only you who undervalues him.

Lip Gallagher

5/18/19 4:59pm

<< Deleted >>

I'mBatman

5/18/19 6:17pm

Cal too - he did have his struggles. Plenty of talent, though.

Coop

5/18/19 6:56pm

He was only a sophomore and he probably didn't play much at ND

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 8:33pm

Oh no! And you judge a player on a game or two? Lol

Lip Gallagher

5/19/19 7:50am

I deleted it because it was probable too harsh

I'mBatman

5/19/19 6:02pm

That dude should be good, I remember that BSU game was bad

Pretorian

5/19/19 5:49am

How many South Carolina games did you watch last year? Just curious.

The Dude Abides

5/18/19 3:21pm

Why do you ask? Just Curious.

Uncle Bluto

5/18/19 5:13pm

Expecting much more from Williams, than his past may suggest is reasonable?

basman

5/18/19 5:30pm

Got it. Honorable mention doesn't seem like a huge stretch.

Uncle Bluto

5/18/19 5:32pm

On the cusp of top 10, maybe unreasonable. People's expectations on here

basman

5/18/19 5:40pm

I’m guessing not many of us at all have seen Williams play. He has Williams in his top 15 or so players?

The Dude Abides

5/18/19 6:16pm

I saw a 40-second film clip where he scored ON EVERY CARRY. Film don't lie.

SingleStrapBackpack

5/18/19 6:19pm

Little surprised you have Katoa in the top 10

Dr T-bone

5/18/19 4:04pm

I'm surprised Moroni isn't on top ten and others haven't chimed in

getdal

5/18/19 4:18pm

Probably because he's been injured so much the last couple years. People have forgotten about him. Let's hope he makes

SingleStrapBackpack

5/18/19 4:50pm

Because he's a SR and hardly done anything in his career and is always injured.

Lip Gallagher

5/18/19 4:58pm

Katoa probably not. Mandell absolutely.

Lip Gallagher

5/18/19 4:56pm

I'd probably break it down by offense/defense

donnerstag

5/18/19 4:58pm

Let's see if Williams is able to learn the playbook, is willing and knows who to

basman

5/18/19 5:28pm

The guy is a wildcard not almost there for sure

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 5:32pm

Missing spring and learning the offense is huge. Don't be surprised if he takes

basman

5/18/19 5:41pm

That’s why I said he’s a wildcard

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 6:47pm

TW is the 2nd coming of Eric Dickerson—Mark it down!

GOUTES1

5/19/19 8:34am

The guy under center, I believe, is the best player on the team

gww687

5/18/19 6:18pm

Don’t confuse best with most important

Pretorian

5/19/19 5:48am

I’m not, I honestly believe he is both.

gww687

5/19/19 7:59am

I expect Tonga and Bushman to both be better. I think they could be All American

puntersarepeople

5/19/19 8:04am

Tonga has to show me he has the work ethic to match the upside

gww687

5/19/19 8:51am

I don’t think Bushman is too soft. I think he’s just needed a QB to properly

puntersarepeople

5/19/19 9:02am

I SO hope you're right!

Pretorian

5/19/19 6:55pm

Hifo not getting enough love

Cougforgood

5/18/19 6:31pm

He’s at least top 15

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 6:48pm

Wilcox? nah

NacoCoug

5/19/19 12:20am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

5/18/19 7:20pm

Agree. Overall impact goes Zach, Tonga, Bushman

puntersarepeople

5/18/19 8:32pm

ZW was unquestionably impactful last year—Julian Blackman says hello!

GOUTES1

5/19/19 8:39am

Wilson should be a lot higher on this list...

icecougar

5/19/19 2:40am

Most impact isn’t the same as best

puntersarepeople

5/19/19 7:28am

Aaaaaaaand top 10 is the same as best?

icecougar

5/19/19 4:00pm

It is on this list

puntersarepeople

5/19/19 4:13pm

I'd probably swap Katoa and Wilcox out for Ty'son and Mandell, personally

Byu_1988

5/19/19 9:59am

For the last 50+ years, the most important guy is the QB.

Yohy

5/19/19 4:12pm

Zach is 7th on this list? Uh, just no.

missourijok

5/19/19 5:49pm

Why not? The other guys ahead of him were studs

puntersarepeople

5/19/19 5:58pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad