by a slim margin even though I will never pay for a set of their irons. I played 1 round with some I borrowed and they had great feel, workability, etc. And they were really good looking clubs. I play taylormade p790 irons currently and had titleist ap2s before. That being said the top level clubs from each company are all really good. Honestly I just think it comes down to what feels right for your swing and what instills the most confidence.