in your own mind. I agree with most of your hot take, but...
Here are a few exceptions I would like your legendariness to comment on:
Ty Detmer
Jim McMahon
Zach Wilson
Jimmer
KVN
Jamal Williams
Taysom
Lavell
Maybe I don't have a good memory, but I am not sure if knives ever came out for any of these guys. I think people started to realize that some of them would not pan out as starters in their respective leagues, or that it was time for someone to move on/retire, but I am not sure about the knife thing.