It doesn't matter who the better player is. It matters who had the better year. If you look at it objectively Randle had a better year than both of the.
Question: Did you know the Jazz were better this year in the regular season with Mitchell on the bench? They put scored opponents by more when he sat. He also missed about 20 games.
Did you know that Booker's 1.1 VORP was less than 1/3 of Randle's 3.8?
These are actual statistics. They seem important. Randle was better this year.