Good list, but I would put Gifford Nielsen in your top 10 and bump Sark to #11

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 29, 2021
9:51:51am

Bumpus Hound Playmaker

Good list, but I would put Gifford Nielsen in your top 10 and bump Sark to #11

I would also swap Detmer and Young

Report problem with this ad

Bumpus Hound

Bio page: Bumpus Hound
Joined: Jan 31, 2002
Last login: May 8, 2024
Total posts: 1,988 (48 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Where do you rank Sarkisian on BYU’s all-time great QB list?

Run-DMT

11/29/21 9:16am

McMahon, Young, Detmer are top 3 in whatever order. Sarkisian, Z. Wilson, Beck

boogers

11/29/21 9:20am

Don't forget about Giff Nielson and Virgil Carter.

HiLife

11/29/21 9:26am

Mark Wilson was also an All-American and NFL starter for many years

AZ Coug

11/29/21 9:28am

I can't believe that I missed him--I saw Wilson and forgot that it was Zach.

HiLife

11/29/21 9:35am

McMahon, Young, Detmer, Bosco, M. Wilson, Z. Wilson, Beck, Sheide, Hall, Sark.

11/29/21 9:26am

I think he's between 8-10. Sheide/Hall/Sarkisian are a toss-up to me.

11/29/21 9:26am

Good list, but I would put Gifford Nielsen in your top 10 and bump Sark to #11

11/29/21 9:51am

Young should've won the Heisman, plus he's in the HOF and won a Super Bowl.

11/29/21 10:00am

He's certainly the most accomplished BYU QB when you consider college and pro

11/29/21 5:16pm

Sark was very smart, a great competitor and had a great team…about 10ish.

Housemartin

11/29/21 9:31am

Sark wasn't the most physically talented guy.

HiLife

11/29/21 9:39am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad