Then they proceeded to say that for their overall ranking,

Aug 19, 2022
1:00:33pm

AF Cougar All-American

They used 19 media members and then aggregated the fan vote (73,000 fans) as a single vote. They threw out outliers - which was usually the fan vote to get their overall ranking.

How is that for disrespecting the fans?

Report problem with this ad

AF Cougar

Bio page: AF Cougar
Joined: Jan 26, 2002
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 12,563 (290 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Good job BYU fans

Blueto

8/19/22 12:44pm

Then they proceeded to say that for their overall ranking,

AF Cougar

8/19/22 1:00pm

"19 media members" - Hans, Socky G, Jake, DJ, Ben Anderson, Scott Mitchell, Nate

Team Chaos

8/19/22 1:11pm

I thought they both had lost their ability to be objective. I stand corrected.

TrueBlue67

8/19/22 1:06pm

And yet they'll argue that Utah gives the Big12 the Utah market right?

runnincoug

8/19/22 1:12pm

Huh, they've listed #11-60 and Rising isn't there, so I don't think that's

Rise Against

8/19/22 2:52pm

because their vote overrules fan vote.

runnincoug

8/19/22 2:53pm

I'm saying that those players aren't listed in the top 60 yet, which means they

Rise Against

8/19/22 2:57pm

The fan vote isn't the same as the actual results

BYUFootballisBack

8/19/22 3:01pm

Thats the whole point, the fan vote had no Utes in the top 10, top 10 is going

BYUFootballisBack

8/19/22 3:00pm

Oh man, I'm an idiot. I kept failing to see that it was the fan vote. My

Rise Against

8/19/22 3:02pm

All good 🙂

BYUFootballisBack

8/19/22 3:08pm

The BYU guys I expect to be in the top 10 are Jaren Hall, Freeland, Barrington,

Rise Against

8/19/22 2:59pm

Only other player outside those 4 I could see is Kingsley, but doubt it

BYUFootballisBack

8/19/22 3:15pm

Yeah, he deserves it, but I don't think they'll put him in since he hasn't

Posting on CougarBoard