I wish I was like many of you and could think Sitake just needs a few more years

May 14, 2024
10:20:59am

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

to turn this around. He may be the only coach in history that has needed over a decade to get his guys in the program.

I think you all are crazy but I love your optimism!

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Mar 18, 2025
Total posts: 55,320 (1,597 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I wish I was like many of you and could think Sitake just needs a few more years

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 10:20am

His guys are in place.

coolblue

5/14/24 10:22am

I think that was his point

Non-mo Coug

5/14/24 10:29am

Thank you.

coolblue

5/14/24 10:33am

Kalani gets unexpected wins every year and has head scratching

VB2

5/14/24 2:34pm

I think the silent majority won’t be so silent if (when) we stumble through another season. KS has shown us his ceiling.

Yllage Vidiot

5/14/24 10:25am

Ceiling is #5 in the Sagarin Ratings?

donnerstag

5/14/24 11:18am

In a year half the teams are playing

ochobeeguy

5/14/24 2:09pm

The best half.

ParentingNotForSissy

5/14/24 2:13pm

RE: Ceiling is #5 in the Sagarin Ratings?

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:10am

The fact that you’re calling the 2020 opponents high schools teams

donnerstag

5/15/24 9:49am

RE: The fact that you’re calling the 2020 opponents high schools teams

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:55am

You might want to review the history of UCF and Houston, because that’s not

donnerstag

5/15/24 10:03am

LOL, it’s as if 2020-2022 never happened

Indy Coug

5/14/24 10:34am

In 2022 we finished 63rd in Sagarin which is about 20 spots lower than Bronco

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 10:37am

Fact check using your own post

donnerstag

5/14/24 10:49am

I have little faith in Kalani making us competitive in the Big 12 but the 2020

Lord Jim

5/14/24 11:35am

One thing is the number 2 draft pick was on the team with multiple others that

davidmj10

5/14/24 5:19pm

6 people gave you a thumbs up even though you were completely wrong

slatecoug

5/14/24 8:35pm

Continue that lie.

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 9:46pm

It's basically a wash if we go by Sagarin SOS

donnerstag

5/15/24 4:02am

So you are going to refute the Sagarin data posted right on this thread?

slatecoug

5/15/24 2:52pm

Did you not see the post right above yours?

kimdaddy35

5/15/24 6:38pm

I wouldn't use 2022 as an example of Kalani being a good coach

BYU Fan

5/14/24 10:45am

It was a middling season that justified dumping the defensive coaches

donnerstag

5/14/24 10:51am

So if we struggle this year and replace some offensive coaches

BYU Fan

5/14/24 10:54am

We already replaced 2 offensive coaches this past offseason

donnerstag

5/14/24 11:00am

It seemed that 2022 was being held up as an example of a good season

BYU Fan

5/14/24 3:07pm

61st is not middling for BYU. It is horrendous.

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 12:34pm

It’s actually top half in the country

donnerstag

5/14/24 12:58pm

Apparently that is where we disagree. You think being in the middle of the

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 1:07pm

We apparently disagree on 2 things

donnerstag

5/14/24 1:19pm

Wow, you are all over the place. First you don't like Sagarin.Care to share why?

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 1:33pm

You read a lot of points I didn’t make

donnerstag

5/14/24 2:13pm

I'm done with the disagreeing, but just so you know preseason factors in 0%

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 8:03pm

You must be the most patient boss in the world

TNT

5/14/24 4:53pm

RE: We apparently disagree on 2 things

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:26am

He can’t recruit worth a dang, but has more players drafted into the NFL than

donnerstag

5/15/24 9:52am

He didn’t dump Tuiaki. He kept him as long as possible till he was forced to.

Frankfromtheballpark

5/15/24 10:52am

Kalani has been much better than Bronco at roster balance and building depth

donnerstag

5/15/24 10:58am

You’d call this QB room stacked? You’d call the DL room stacked?

Frankfromtheballpark

5/15/24 11:48am

I said “packed” if you read my post

donnerstag

5/15/24 11:57am

Haha, just because he packed the position groups doesn’t mean he’s a good coach

Frankfromtheballpark

5/15/24 3:21pm

The packing has helped even the weakest position group

donnerstag

5/15/24 4:06pm

We are in a P4 Conference. There are roughly 70 P4 teams. Coming in at #61

BYUMizzou

5/14/24 2:03pm

We have been P4 for one season

donnerstag

5/14/24 2:14pm

Money and recruiting won’t fix head scratcher plays that hurt the team

coastcat

5/14/24 7:32pm

I like how you pretend there weren’t extenuating circumstances those years

Frankfromtheballpark

5/14/24 4:33pm

What were the extenuating circumstances of 2021?

donnerstag

5/14/24 5:11pm

The only success Kalani has had was because of the Covid years.

Frankfromtheballpark

5/14/24 6:20pm

Many forget how he went 4-9, 7-6 & 7-6 before covid. Yes, Kalani went

gopman

5/14/24 7:49pm

Funny narrative

donnerstag

5/14/24 8:05pm

RE: LOL, it’s as if 2020-2022 never happened

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:12am

<< Deleted >>

BYU Fan

5/14/24 10:44am

What will the next wave of excuses be?

BigHouse Coug

5/14/24 10:48am

The "we can't get anyone better" excuse seems a little weak after the MBB hiring

BYU Fan

5/14/24 10:53am

So Kalani’s assistants are good enough to improve the program, get more wins,

Polecat

5/14/24 12:08pm

Also the MBB hiring is something entirely different and new than what BYU has

Polecat

5/14/24 12:10pm

Yea, who's the top LDS assistant coach in the NFL, a future NFL HC, that BYU can

BYURider

5/14/24 1:18pm

Closest comparison is probably Kellen Moore…who BYU will never get

arcawley

5/14/24 4:55pm

Not true. Reports are Kellen Moore is open to becoming a head

gopman

5/14/24 7:57pm

IMO Moore is a perfect comparison to Young and wouldn’t come coach BYU

arcawley

5/14/24 7:59pm

Huh? They're all MASSIVE upgrades & are very realistic thanks

gopman

5/14/24 8:05pm

Who says the MBB hiring is "anyone better". Time will tell…

ochobeeguy

5/14/24 2:10pm

Probably something about watching film. And then looking completely unprepared

TNT

5/14/24 4:53pm

RE: Probably something about watching film. And then looking completely

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:35am

My question is who is going to replace him?

BYU Grounds

5/14/24 3:21pm

Is this always the answer at BYU? "Well there is nobody else"

TNT

5/14/24 4:55pm

Exactly - KY came out of nowhere. We can do this again in Football…

Riggins Rigs

5/14/24 5:16pm

KY needs to produce. Everybody acts like he is a proven commodity. Far from that

fan32

5/14/24 6:47pm

Well - let’s take a look at his career trajectory vs Kalani’s before BYU called

Riggins Rigs

5/14/24 7:28pm

Before coming to BYU, Kalani was the defensive

BYURider

5/14/24 7:42pm

And it's very clear that the Utah gig was much more Whitt than KS

TNT

5/14/24 8:05pm

And the Oregon St defense I think is one of if not the worst in their history.

kimdaddy35

5/14/24 8:26pm

RE: KY needs to produce. Everybody acts like he is a proven commodity. Far from

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:36am

Andy Reid aint coming through that door and we don't have a KY equivalent in football.

TheLoneCougar

5/14/24 10:06pm

KY was on BYU's Succession Plan Board, Wonder who is on the football board

Dr T-bone

5/14/24 5:26pm

Jay Hill

BlueZone

5/14/24 7:41pm

Darrell Bevell, Kellen Moore, Lance Anderson, Ken N, Bronco, Jay Hill,

gopman

5/14/24 8:04pm

I’m just grateful it isn’t you

Unibro

5/14/24 5:53pm

Kalani's big problem now is that he has held on to A-Rod for too long

BlueZone

5/14/24 7:41pm

At this point, the question is will he last long enough to fire his assistants?

BigHouse Coug

5/15/24 1:51pm

So on board w this…Covid saved him.

rmarkerm

5/14/24 8:21pm

RE: So on board w this…Covid saved him.

imdocrob

5/15/24 9:38am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad