About the same as if he doesn't decide to come back.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 25, 2015
11:45:45am

lightmann All-American

About the same as if he doesn't decide to come back.

Report problem with this ad

lightmann

Previous username: llightmann
Bio page: lightmann
Joined: Aug 3, 2004
Last login: May 28, 2024
Total posts: 36,545 (493 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If we finish 10-3 and Taysom decides to come back next year...

Cougarrrs

11/24/15 11:12pm

Honestly, I'd be surprised if we made a pre-season top 25. I think we need to

Bergloewe

11/24/15 11:18pm

Really depends how much height we have at WR that could put us

franklyvulgar

11/24/15 11:25pm

The correct answer is

Seaward

11/24/15 11:28pm

even mid season they are worthless. Remember when utah was getting 1st place vot

buckeyecougarguy

11/24/15 11:39pm

Yeah, college football should outlaw third parties from speculation prior to

Cougarrrs

11/25/15 12:19am

No they are not stupid and they help determine how long BYU can stay relevant

nashty

11/25/15 12:30am

Who cares? Tv stations, advertisers, donors, season ticket buyers, athletic gear sellers, players,

HarlemCoug

11/25/15 1:50am

correct--a better question would be: what fan DOESN'T care?

BYUtiful

11/25/15 5:00am

The NFL seems to do fine w advertisers without totally arbitrary rankings.

Seaward

11/25/15 6:58pm

yeah, because that's an apples-to-apples comparison

BYUtiful

11/26/15 5:40am

Comparing football to football. How foolish of me.

Seaward

11/26/15 8:29am

There are 32 NFL teams. Not really the same as the college landscape.

Cougarrrs

11/26/15 10:20am

Still doesn't justify an arbitrary ranking system before a down has been played.

Seaward

11/26/15 11:09am

Obviously the pre-season rankings are far from perfect but they're based on

Cougarrrs

11/26/15 11:21am

i would re-read what has been said by harlem & myself

BYUtiful

11/26/15 1:02pm

I never said to eliminate the ranking system. I said wait a few weeks.

Seaward

11/26/15 3:59pm

I care. Its almost impossible to reach top10 unless you start in top 25.

MormonThug

11/25/15 7:23am

Yep, just look at Iowa, Michigan and Oklahoma State. Unless if by impossible,

cougaman

11/25/15 7:42am

* almost

MormonThug

11/25/15 7:51am

This is just not true at all

CasualFan

11/25/15 8:02am

crap. thats the 2nd time i've been wrong.

MormonThug

11/25/15 8:28am

You must not be married.

CasualFan

11/25/15 8:42am

It's likely we'll see our highest pre-season rank since 2009 w/ or w/out Taysom

SpiffCoug

11/25/15 6:54am

The new MO is for no more than 1 non-P5/BCS team to appear in the preseason rank

BYUFam1

11/25/15 8:21am

DL, DB, OL ~ must have more depth

RealityCheckedCougr

11/25/15 8:32am

Not even in the Top 25...you have to earn that and we haven't.

IronPotato

11/25/15 8:54am

Look for it......next year

chestercougar

11/25/15 9:46am

Just outside top 25

11/25/15 11:29am

About the same as if he doesn't decide to come back.

lightmann

11/25/15 11:45am

Not ranked but probably receiving some votes. About #35 L

byuTX

11/27/15 7:11am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad