My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 23, 2016
4:43
:40
pm
jomo
All-American
If Tanner won every game... we can play the "IF.." game all day long
Smart coaching tells you that unless there is a clear decision, go with an experienced senior and let your underclassman develop.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
jomo
Bio page
jomo
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Last login
Oct 8, 2019
Total posts
3,954 (8 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
For those that want Taysom to start
digitalayon
6/22/16 7:35pm
No.
DrKennethNoisewater
6/22/16 7:37pm
No.
Cougarrr
6/22/16 7:42pm
Nobody knew if Taysom was even coming back
Seasider
6/22/16 7:42pm
No.
Jericho
6/22/16 7:48pm
No
Blue Ghost
6/22/16 7:54pm
No.
beebs4lyfe
6/22/16 7:55pm
Yes. Taysom cant stay healthy
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 7:56pm
Except during his run first sophomore season, 2013.
basman
6/22/16 8:22pm
Well as long as we are delving into the past, how'd we finish that year?
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 8:57pm
Well, if you recall, Taysom was very much a run first QB and if ever there was
basman
6/22/16 9:14pm
K, but that was an easy schedule. To counter your counter, he just hasn't stayed
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 9:43pm
So it's easier to stay healthy against an easier schedule? Ask Riley about
basman
6/22/16 9:59pm
That schedule ranked 38th on Sagarin - try another one
Coop
6/23/16 1:54pm
wrong, that schedule was the toughest in Bronco's career. It was ranked...
icecougar
6/23/16 8:36pm
Here are the 28 current P5 teams with a worse SOS than BYU in 2013
BYUFam1
6/25/16 9:19am
What does his health history have to do with anything? If he gets hurt, then
Kerbouchard
6/22/16 8:28pm
Health history has a lot to do with everything BYU
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 8:56pm
Yup, I think the exact same way. SO WHAT IF HE GETS HURT!? That only truly
Duke Silver
6/22/16 11:06pm
Because you waste time giving him starter reps
shakarocks
6/23/16 8:09am
There are 3 words that should never come out of a man's mouth, for any reason,
jaba166
6/25/16 2:08am
Made that mistake once.
Boxey
6/25/16 11:30am
It applies to all football players
shakarocks
6/25/16 11:38am
I "guaranfreakintee" you that you can't "guaranfreakintee" me anything about
jaba166
6/26/16 3:29am
Of courses I can
shakarocks
6/26/16 12:16pm
Well that's dumb. The question wasn't who stays healthier.
RaggaeCoug
6/23/16 8:23am
No...Taysom gives us the best chance to win.
RichieRich
6/22/16 8:02pm
How do you figure? His win % and Tanners are basically a push.
Blueto
6/22/16 9:05pm
Because I have eyes and a brain.
RichieRich
6/22/16 9:16pm
One of those two things is debatable.
The Board Idiot
6/22/16 9:20pm
It's the eyes isn't it.
jaredm
6/22/16 9:50pm
the white cane, dog and dark shades gave him away
icecougar
6/23/16 8:37pm
And Tanner had NO running game to boot
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/22/16 9:41pm
Winning % is not only about the QB - it's about protection, skill positions,
jaba166
6/26/16 3:46am
No kidding? Well despite all that TH and TM win football games at the same rate
Blueto
6/26/16 1:41pm
C'mon man. That's HIGHLY debatable at this point...even
mantis mutu
6/23/16 10:09am
no.
BYUALWAYSNUM1
6/22/16 8:10pm
No.
Bgash
6/22/16 8:12pm
No
CopperLix
6/22/16 8:16pm
No.
bbqoug
6/22/16 8:17pm
No, why would it?
Kerbouchard
6/22/16 8:27pm
No, TM is awesome but TH has the experience to go with his freakish ability
ImuaKahuku
6/22/16 8:28pm
He had only started 6 ish more games...
AzCoug1
6/22/16 10:06pm
6 yrs film study, game planning, college coaching...
ImuaKahuku
6/22/16 10:50pm
Yes? Go on....
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:34am
vs 1 yr film study, 1 yr college coaching, 1 yr... experience does matter
ImuaKahuku
6/23/16 8:52am
Nope. It has to do with how he dictates to a defense.
CaliWG
6/22/16 8:50pm
no
HarlemCoug
6/22/16 8:53pm
Nope. Had Taysom played in that game it wouldn't have been close. BYU wins by touchdowns
MaxxPower
6/22/16 9:08pm
No. Tanner is so good, he'll pick defenses apart--mostly methodically, but will
RebelScum
6/22/16 9:22pm
Nope
Epileptic Beagle
6/22/16 9:26pm
No
Rhino84
6/22/16 9:28pm
No
mexcoug
6/22/16 9:29pm
I side with everyone else. Nope.
The Dude Abides
6/22/16 9:57pm
No
8theU
6/22/16 10:11pm
No
AF Cougar
6/22/16 10:13pm
No
ashkii49
6/22/16 10:31pm
You can say "had ___ beaten Utah" for every QB since Max Hall.
CrimsonCardinal
6/22/16 10:33pm
Yes.
ragid
6/22/16 10:46pm
I am fine with Detmer deciding this. Either could do really well
Accipiter
6/22/16 10:59pm
No.
Machiavelli
6/22/16 11:26pm
No, watching him BEAT Texas did.
byucougarsbig12
6/22/16 11:41pm
Maybe. Probably not.
Gerald-DeGroot
6/23/16 12:04am
No. I saw enough at Nebraska. Passing was on point.
QC Cougar
6/23/16 12:18am
Using Neb as a measuring stick is confessing: "I saw
mantis mutu
6/23/16 10:31am
This year and last year
viper
6/23/16 11:18am
This
shakarocks
6/23/16 11:33am
Tell it to Detmer. (He lobbied pretty hard for Taysom to come back)
Y2k
6/23/16 12:49pm
Why wouldn't he lobby him?
shakarocks
6/23/16 12:55pm
Exactly. He judged him based on what he saw.
Y2k
6/23/16 1:20pm
Detmer would've been stupid not to lobby hard for him.
mantis mutu
6/23/16 1:50pm
Best Man Wins
shakarocks
6/23/16 3:16pm
Ideally I want Tanner to start and win game 1. I want him to start game 2
Y2k
6/24/16 1:27pm
Can he improve as a passer? I suppose so. He was at 66 percent of his passes
JamesWestfall
6/23/16 12:55pm
You've got a whole thread here full of people
shakarocks
6/23/16 1:16pm
Because of poor protection, perhaps???
jaba166
6/26/16 3:53am
Yes he looked great against one of the worst pass defenses in all of C FB
CarolinaCoug
6/23/16 6:05pm
Bout to ruffle some feathers but here's how this debate feels to me
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:52am
You've got one more year with the hot girl, so enjoy it. The close friend will
Ulysses14
6/23/16 5:05am
RE: Bout to ruffle some feathers but here's how this debate feels to me
B-town_coug
6/23/16 6:28am
That is one of the worst analogies I've ever heard, and is quite offensive
jdub
6/23/16 6:43am
Your feathers got ruffled
shakarocks
6/23/16 8:12am
My feathers got ruffled because the analogy was really, really bad
jdub
6/23/16 8:28am
Yeah, it'd be more accurate to say your hot GF got injured from being so hot
boogers
6/23/16 8:41am
Do u usually interpret everything in the most literal sense?
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 10:17am
Analogy, by nature, are meant to be interpreted. It was a terrible analogy
runnincoug
6/23/16 1:10pm
You realize that analogies by definition are not literal, right?
jdub
6/23/16 1:57pm
Hence the "literal" comment
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 3:21pm
First, you should admit it was a bad analogy, because it was
jdub
6/23/16 3:32pm
U serious Clark?
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 5:06pm
The problem is that girl 2 is still a little too young for you
viper
6/23/16 7:59am
Well played
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 1:10pm
The difference: Taysom gives you the chance to win every game
CaliWG
6/23/16 8:27am
Very good points! Totally agree on Taysom - he is not a work in progress at all
jaba166
6/26/16 3:42am
This post made me lol so hard. Well done sir
Ulysses14
6/23/16 10:45am
So if Tanner has the great year you are predicting, what keeps him from going to the NFL after the season?
Rhino84
6/23/16 10:57am
Ugh. My point for THIS yr is the likelihood of hill being the starter and
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:01pm
If you're a polygamist, you can enjoy the benefits of both. No reason to choose.
Accipiter
6/23/16 12:02pm
<< Deleted >>
Ulysses14
6/23/16 12:12pm
One, the analogy is awful. Two, you aren't considering everything
CFMcK
6/23/16 12:44pm
2
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:51pm
Yeah, you still start Taysom
CFMcK
6/23/16 1:00pm
Taysom hasn't ever played in a dropback system, so his health issues
Accipiter
6/23/16 1:03pm
Meh
shakarocks
6/23/16 1:14pm
And what an actual running game adds to Tanners production for 1st time
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 3:32pm
Designed QB runs aren't what makes Taysom special
CFMcK
6/23/16 5:01pm
Either way
shakarocks
6/23/16 5:40pm
I expect we will still get much of what Taysom does best, I think while
Accipiter
6/23/16 7:53pm
who POTD this?!
Dissenter
6/23/16 3:36pm
SO MANY TYPOS...AHH
Machiavelli
6/23/16 3:48pm
That's really a question? No.
coolblue
6/23/16 6:42am
No.
Zilog
6/23/16 7:54am
Really wish the taysom v tanner threads would just go away. can't possibly
dccoug
6/23/16 10:09am
Totally agree!!!!! Let the coaches decide, and just be glad we have both QB's!
jaba166
6/26/16 3:50am
No!
buckowens
6/23/16 10:13am
No!
fulano
6/23/16 10:44am
Tanner is great. However, he was getting away with a lot of chuck and duck
fulano
6/23/16 10:50am
Both have leadership ability and both move the offense
shakarocks
6/23/16 11:24am
Agreed. If it wasn't for those 2 hail mary's we would've lost our first 4 games
Hill4Heisman
6/23/16 12:22pm
No. Tanner is the future, but Taysom (if healthy)
byumac
6/23/16 12:31pm
no
Qbcougg
6/23/16 1:04pm
Both in the backfield at once. You choose how
HangookCoug
6/23/16 1:30pm
RE: For those that want Taysom to start
Lionaround
6/23/16 3:24pm
If Tanner won every game... we can play the "IF.." game all day long
jomo
6/23/16 4:43pm
No
GSwarriorcoug
6/23/16 5:01pm
no
yakkamole
6/23/16 5:33pm
No
ZooBlue
6/23/16 6:21pm
No
icecougar
6/23/16 8:32pm
Tanner > Taysom
provodude84606
6/24/16 7:36am
Troll
jensen46
6/24/16 9:07am
Taysom is good...
provodude84606
6/24/16 10:25am
Interesting how you criticize people for hanging on to "what if's" regarding
jaba166
6/26/16 4:07am
I agree
BYuckner
6/24/16 10:29am
no
Yakov
6/24/16 2:58pm
Agree. I love watching taysom, but his legacy
AzCoug1
6/24/16 5:22pm
No
Yakov
6/25/16 6:18am
Prove it
AzCoug1
6/25/16 7:28am
No
Yakov
6/25/16 11:45pm
Yummy....
Pride
6/24/16 9:07am
Seriously. Look at all these "what if's".....
BabyOx
6/24/16 10:11am
no
GritHead
6/25/16 11:11am
NO
Wear Blue
6/25/16 11:40am
RE: For those that want Taysom to start
cougaman
6/25/16 5:34pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad