Like ur hot girlfriend (a 9) cheats on u 3 times but promises she'll never do it again; when u have a close friend who's a 7 now but only because she's not always dressing to show off her body so might be a 9, and is honest to a fault and treats u like a king has wanted to date u for years.
Option 1 will never last and option 2 is who goes down as the best decision u ever made and u kick yourself for not seeing it sooner. Omviously drastic reference but Taysom is so electric but can't stay in the field. Tanners abilities after limited prep and never playing a game in college is barely (if not equal) behind. Say Taysom starts and BYU wins 10, Tanner starts and wins 9. Is there a drastically different outcome THIS year? Nope. But Taysom's gone next year and value to the PROGRAM to have Tanner start this year and progress over following 2yrs IS the best option. Unless Taysom somehow Finds a way to play in 2017 we have a qb who's essentially reverting back to where he was at start of last year. Watching the game helps him improve but sitting for a year makes that benefit minimal. With Tanner we could have a good ur this ur and an elite ye after that. Taysom starts and it's a good yr in 2016 and a good yr in 2017