And it's not even close. Taysom is a pipe dream and will go down as a BYU legend no matter what he does (or doesn't do). He hasn't done anything to warrant the way BYU fans geek about him. His BYU career is ALL 'what if's' and when he gets hurt again, he'll have more what if's to add to his what if collection.
Tanner didn't need to win the Utah game for me to say he's BYUs best choice at QB until he leaves.