I think an expanded playoff would probably be worse for BYU

Aug 28, 2014
1:40:11pm

2RUEBLUE

With 8 teams, it'd be hard to keep out a 1 loss Texas or Oklahoma, even if they didn't have a CCG. If they're kept out under the current system, there seems to be more motivation for them to have a CCG which would mean expansion.

Report problem with this ad

2RUEBLUE

New username: Thunder Buddy
Bio page: 2RUEBLUE
Joined: Dec 15, 2011
Last login: Jan 8, 2015
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The College Football Playoff will be different than a lot of people are

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:26pm

There will be so much campaigning and arguing

gustav88

8/28/14 1:29pm

yeah the more I think about it the easier it is to see the b12 being left out

johnnycarson

8/28/14 1:29pm

The last weekend, the committee will see SEC, P12, B1G, and ACC champ games

boscatar

8/28/14 1:38pm

However, some of those CCG will also feature an unranked team (6-6 UCLA?)

BYUFam1

8/28/14 1:46pm

That was a fluke, though. USC was 10-2 but was ineligible.

mannheimadler

8/28/14 3:55pm

When was the last time BYU ran the table or finished top 5?

2RUEBLUE

8/28/14 1:31pm

BYU would have had a shot in 2001 and 1996 - but likely would not have made it.

boscatar

8/28/14 1:33pm

BYU was ranked #7 at the end of the 1996 regular season. They would have had

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:35pm

BYU was #5 on December 9, 1996

boscatar

8/28/14 1:44pm

Good catch. I was looking at the 2nd to last poll. At #5, BYU would have had an

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:51pm

Here is the deal

BYUFam1

8/28/14 1:53pm

Agree.

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:56pm

1996

Mikey

8/28/14 1:33pm

I think an expanded playoff would probably be worse for BYU

2RUEBLUE

8/28/14 1:40pm

Look at past rankings. Most of the time, there are only 3-5 1 loss teams.

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:47pm

But the chances of an undefeated BYU team with 3-5 good P5 opponents on the

2RUEBLUE

8/28/14 1:52pm

Logic fail.

Blue Print

8/28/14 2:05pm

Read the post.

Lanai

8/28/14 2:10pm

One possibility.

Blue Cat

8/28/14 2:11pm

Are people really expecting 4 conference champs?

boscatar

8/28/14 1:32pm

Many, many media outlets have been speculating about which conference

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:34pm

Which is most likely to be left out is probably more accurate

BYUFam1

8/28/14 1:49pm

Sometimes. Obviously, there are references to both. As you will notice, I

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:53pm

Still better than the BCS, but 8 will be better still

lawboy

8/28/14 1:39pm

It will take a couple of conferences being consistently shut out and raising a

Mikey

8/28/14 1:43pm

No, they'll see how much money they can make, and will switch.

lawboy

8/28/14 1:50pm

Not different than I expect

BYUFam1

8/28/14 1:42pm

Not sure you're correct here. Top 4 rated teams according to whom?

Hoosier Coug

8/28/14 1:52pm

Exactly. With a historical comparison, I think you have to look at wins and

Gentleman Stan

8/28/14 1:54pm

Nobody said it would jive with the AP poll

BYUFam1

8/28/14 1:58pm

Thanks for the correction. Stupid of them to be releasing their ranking before

Hoosier Coug

8/28/14 2:03pm

I have a primer (that evolved) if you care to read it

BYUFam1

8/28/14 2:08pm

RE: Not different than I expect

ManicBlue

8/28/14 1:53pm

I generally agree with your point

Blue Cat

8/28/14 1:45pm

I can see that. I think it would have gone the other way, but obviously there is

Posting on CougarBoard