I would too. Taysom never beat Utah and never finished ranked in the top 25.

Report problem with this ad

Mar 28, 2017
6:30:56pm

RdF3 All-American

Report problem with this ad

RdF3

Previous username: swishh_15
Bio page: RdF3
Joined: Nov 4, 2011
Last login: Jun 13, 2024
Total posts: 40,367 (2,678 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

List QBs in order of legendary status

libertycoug 3rd String

3/28/17 4:26pm

Tanner by the end of next year will be 7 or higher.

BDAWG

3/28/17 4:34pm

pretty good but I would put Shiede at # 7...he was the first great Edwards QB

Nat Gas Man

3/28/17 4:34pm

I thought Ty was #14

IceBlueCoug

3/28/17 4:44pm

Good list. I would put Max Hall higher. At worst #5

frontrowcougar

3/28/17 4:46pm

Yep. My only change is to move Max to 5. All time winningest qb deserves top 5 legendary status

MaxxPower

3/29/17 8:29am

3. Young; Sheide and Carter higher...before Beck and Hall...to be legendary, one

84 Grad

3/28/17 4:48pm

Corrected to Sark. But I disagree about Hill not doing anything legendary

libertycoug

3/28/17 5:45pm

Sark is so underappreciated, easily top 6-7. Only knock is 2 years rather than 4

Tygger

3/28/17 4:53pm

Taysom ahead of Sark?

RdF3

3/28/17 4:59pm

I'd even put Doman over Hill. wins over Utah combined with end of Lavells run

yfootball

3/28/17 6:24pm

I would too. Taysom never beat Utah and never finished ranked in the top 25.

RdF3

3/28/17 6:30pm

McMahon tier 1. Bosco, Detmer and Young tier 2. For tier 3: Wilson, Sheide

HoustonCougar

3/28/17 5:22pm

Agreed. Large gap between McMahon and #2

ALUF 1990

3/28/17 6:11pm

I like the tier system, but how do you keep Heisman winner, National champ, and Steve Young out of the top tier?

libertycoug

3/28/17 8:12pm

Not best QB, but legendary status QB. M. Hall and J. Beck legendary for what they did to Utah just

libertycoug

3/28/17 8:24pm

How is McMahon ahead of Detmer? Completely disagree but you must have some

mcrsj

3/28/17 9:17pm

Did you see them play? A healthy McMahon was the best QB in NCAA by a mile

ALUF 1990

3/29/17 5:24pm

I hate it but I agree completely with this dirty Ute McMahon is #1 easily

pistol12

3/29/17 9:10pm

I'm sending the phrase "dirty ute" to the department of redundancy department for investigation

libertycoug

3/30/17 9:16am

John Walsh?

1-Wing RCAF

3/28/17 5:29pm

Off the cuff (College Career only)...

Katewot

3/28/17 5:45pm

Any list tbat does not include a Heisman trophy winner in the top tier

LifeLongLakerFan

3/28/17 6:14pm

Jimmy Mac is #1. Period.

pistol12

3/28/17 7:00pm

Bosco over young? I don't think so..

Harrison0Yfan

3/28/17 7:28pm

Hill? Seriously?

Gerald-DeGroot

3/28/17 8:19pm

Young, McMahon, Detmer....

rockhound

3/28/17 8:54pm

*NIELSEN!!!! WHY CANT PEOPLE SPELL IT RIGHT?!?!?!?

Circaman12

3/28/17 9:49pm

^^THIS!!!!!!

Kerbouchard

3/28/17 10:29pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad