My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 28, 2017
4:26
:12
pm
libertycoug
3rd String
List QBs in order of legendary status
Here's mine:
1. Ty
2. McMahon
3. Bosco
4. Young
5. Wilson
6. Nielson
7t. Beck
7t. Hall
9. Hill
10. Sark
11 Shiede
12. Carter
13. Doman
Beyond Doman I think legendary falls off, but still some greats anyway
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Mar 28, 2017 at 4:26:12pm
Message modified by libertycoug on Mar 28, 2017 at 5:37:39pm
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
libertycoug
Bio page
libertycoug
Joined
Aug 19, 2013
Last login
Apr 29, 2024
Total posts
2,214 (17 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Related Threads
Topic:
they were talking about Taysom's Pro Day numbers on "The Horn" in Austin
(Kerbouchard, Mar 28, 2017 at 10:05am)
Messages
Author
Time
List QBs in order of legendary status
libertycoug
3rd String
3/28/17 4:26pm
Tanner by the end of next year will be 7 or higher.
BDAWG
3/28/17 4:34pm
pretty good but I would put Shiede at # 7...he was the first great Edwards QB
Nat Gas Man
3/28/17 4:34pm
I thought Ty was #14
IceBlueCoug
3/28/17 4:44pm
Good list. I would put Max Hall higher. At worst #5
frontrowcougar
3/28/17 4:46pm
Yep. My only change is to move Max to 5. All time winningest qb deserves top 5 legendary status
MaxxPower
3/29/17 8:29am
3. Young; Sheide and Carter higher...before Beck and Hall...to be legendary, one
84 Grad
3/28/17 4:48pm
Corrected to Sark. But I disagree about Hill not doing anything legendary
libertycoug
3/28/17 5:45pm
Sark is so underappreciated, easily top 6-7. Only knock is 2 years rather than 4
Tygger
3/28/17 4:53pm
Taysom ahead of Sark?
RdF3
3/28/17 4:59pm
I'd even put Doman over Hill. wins over Utah combined with end of Lavells run
yfootball
3/28/17 6:24pm
I would too. Taysom never beat Utah and never finished ranked in the top 25.
RdF3
3/28/17 6:30pm
McMahon tier 1. Bosco, Detmer and Young tier 2. For tier 3: Wilson, Sheide
HoustonCougar
3/28/17 5:22pm
Agreed. Large gap between McMahon and #2
ALUF 1990
3/28/17 6:11pm
I like the tier system, but how do you keep Heisman winner, National champ, and Steve Young out of the top tier?
libertycoug
3/28/17 8:12pm
Not best QB, but legendary status QB. M. Hall and J. Beck legendary for what they did to Utah just
libertycoug
3/28/17 8:24pm
How is McMahon ahead of Detmer? Completely disagree but you must have some
mcrsj
3/28/17 9:17pm
Did you see them play? A healthy McMahon was the best QB in NCAA by a mile
ALUF 1990
3/29/17 5:24pm
I hate it but I agree completely with this dirty Ute
McMahon is #1 easily
pistol12
3/29/17 9:10pm
I'm sending the phrase "dirty ute" to the department of redundancy department for investigation
libertycoug
3/30/17 9:16am
John Walsh?
1-Wing RCAF
3/28/17 5:29pm
Off the cuff (College Career only)...
Katewot
3/28/17 5:45pm
Any list tbat does not include a Heisman trophy winner in the top tier
LifeLongLakerFan
3/28/17 6:14pm
Jimmy Mac is #1. Period.
pistol12
3/28/17 7:00pm
Bosco over young? I don't think so..
Harrison0Yfan
3/28/17 7:28pm
Hill? Seriously?
Gerald-DeGroot
3/28/17 8:19pm
Young, McMahon, Detmer....
rockhound
3/28/17 8:54pm
*NIELSEN!!!! WHY CANT PEOPLE SPELL IT RIGHT?!?!?!?
Circaman12
3/28/17 9:49pm
^^THIS!!!!!!
Kerbouchard
3/28/17 10:29pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad