My Account
Report problem with this ad
Nov 14, 2017
12:11
:31
pm
TheLost
Walk-on
<< Deleted >>
double post
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Nov 14, 2017 at 12:11:31pm
Message modified by TheLost on Nov 14, 2017 at 12:12:30pm
Message modified by TheLost on Nov 14, 2017 at 12:18:37pm
Report problem with this ad
TheLost
Bio page
TheLost
Joined
Jun 30, 2017
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
20,136 (311 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Only one 4 Star Recruit?
vabeachcoug
11/13/17 9:55pm
There were several others but they've changed their commitment to Utah.
ToasterChive
11/13/17 9:58pm
You mean 1 right?
Turnpike Lane
11/13/17 9:59pm
I don't know. Some olineman and other defensive players. Can't recall names but it was past 2-3 months.
ToasterChive
11/13/17 10:02pm
Two Herriman kids
I'mBatman
11/13/17 10:29pm
Not to clear Bernard?
ToasterChive
11/13/17 10:35pm
Looks like is an understatement. BYU had ample reason. Any school picking him up
gwalker
11/13/17 10:36pm
<< Deleted >>
dYrtbYkerYder
11/14/17 8:20am
OP was about 4 stars though. None of these guys are 4 star recruits.
Lip Gallagher
11/13/17 10:51pm
FYI... Krump is only a 3 star
TheLost
11/14/17 10:09am
He has offers from bigtime schools though
I'mBatman
11/14/17 11:52am
Serious? That's the last position you should worry about them recruiting.
Lip Gallagher
11/14/17 1:53pm
Who's the Whitt relative DL?
SingleStrapBackpack
11/14/17 1:59pm
Jackson Cravens is KWhitt's nephew I believe.
Lip Gallagher
11/14/17 2:13pm
Didn't know the Whittingham and Cravens families were related
SingleStrapBackpack
11/14/17 2:14pm
All I know is what I've seen on the field
I'mBatman
11/14/17 7:46pm
What happened to Pili this year? Has he been hurt? Showed promise last year but haven't seen much in 2017.
SingleStrapBackpack
11/14/17 7:51pm
Uh, the fact that all of the highest end talent is in their first year says
Lip Gallagher
11/14/17 8:00pm
Maybe some of those young guys you mentioned will be really good
I'mBatman
11/14/17 8:46pm
What are you really missing out on though in your "building" process
Lip Gallagher
11/14/17 9:00pm
"certain transfer from a certain school"? C'mon, man!
SingleStrapBackpack
11/14/17 11:16pm
The recruiting services are 90% certain he is going to Alabama or Washington
Cougtruth
11/13/17 10:06pm
Who is the “he” here?
SingleStrapBackpack
11/13/17 11:21pm
Kaho
wilsdad
11/14/17 4:54am
Some of those guys are going to get reevaluated
cougarmanguy
11/13/17 10:20pm
We’re BYU, not Alabama or Clemson
Modiolus
11/14/17 6:44am
We never get a lot of high-star recruits. That has always been true.
TailgateU
11/14/17 7:03am
We are nowhere near Alabama or Clemson. No need to compare.
TheLoneCougar
11/14/17 7:09am
I know on average 5 stars are just flat out better athletes but having a star at all puts a player
Refugee
11/14/17 7:41am
This year's recruiting class is below average, even for BYU. Bad timing as well.
dYrtbYkerYder
11/14/17 8:21am
A lot fo NFL players arent 5 stars because theres only ~30 of those a year.
molodyets
11/14/17 9:07am
Consider this question though:
CalgaryCougar
11/14/17 9:08am
If you are a 5 star its because you deserve it. Same with the majority of 4
molodyets
11/14/17 9:11am
The quality of recruiting classes is strongly correlated with on-field results.
dYrtbYkerYder
11/14/17 9:30am
The team with a better roster talent wins ~80% of the time if you compare 247
molodyets
11/14/17 9:48am
Yes, and national champions have almost always had recent Top 5 classes.
dYrtbYkerYder
11/14/17 11:10am
That's exactly the point
CalgaryCougar
11/14/17 11:23am
Only ten 4 star recruits signed with non-P5 teams last year.
blackshirts
11/14/17 10:15am
The star system is rigged.. the cart is before the horse
TheLost
11/14/17 10:21am
So 1 out of how many? Stars matter. In last years draft, 23 of the available 31
molodyets
11/14/17 10:25am
Missing my point..
TheLost
11/14/17 10:42am
So what you are saying is that the opinion of guys who
molodyets
11/14/17 11:01am
You are ranked by the offers you have...
TheLost
11/14/17 11:23am
There are always outliers.
Cougstreak
11/14/17 11:31am
Yet the raw data shows that stars directly correlates to getting drafted.
molodyets
11/14/17 11:31am
And winning. Of course there are exceptions, but stars are not meaningless.
dYrtbYkerYder
11/14/17 12:45pm
Read this article. I doubt 50% of 2/3 star guys get drafted.
Cougstreak
11/14/17 11:44am
Still not getting my point...
TheLost
11/14/17 11:59am
You are talking in circles!
Cougstreak
11/14/17 12:02pm
<< Deleted >>
TheLost
11/14/17 12:11pm
Does this clear it up?
TheLost
11/14/17 12:18pm
We are BYU not Bama/ND/USC/Ohio State, we are not getting mainly 4/5 star kids.
Cougstreak
11/14/17 12:36pm
We still have one left? Don’t worry KS is way better at recruiting
Pretorian
11/14/17 10:46am
We ought to be able to out recruit Kansas, but maybe not.
Cougtruth
11/14/17 4:35pm
Report problem with this ad
Report problem with this ad