Apr 6, 2024
4:27:37pm
4:27:37pm
I said it was common sense, and then I put forth the evidence from a systematic review/meta analysis.
I'm sorry that for some reason you think 3x ACL tears = no biggie.
I'm not sure where you are going with your linked article anyway. It supports my common sense conclusion too. Great, there is a graft procedure. Cool, I know this.
But on to the conclusion from your own article:
"In the NFL, only 61% of defensive players who underwent ACLR successfully returned to play at least half a season. They also tended to retire sooner and to have fewer appearances and a decreased number of solo tackles."
This article is essentially useless in proving anything. It is talking about different techniques, neither of which you or I know Fano went through.
One again my friend, please keep thinking that 3 ACL tears is meaningless. I've provided a study, you've provided a study, and we've seen first hand evidence in Keenan Pili that support my claim. Outliers exist and I would gladly see Logan Fano come back and due well (outside of playing well in any BYU game), but statistically speaking that isn't likely to happen.
I'm not sure where you are going with your linked article anyway. It supports my common sense conclusion too. Great, there is a graft procedure. Cool, I know this.
But on to the conclusion from your own article:
"In the NFL, only 61% of defensive players who underwent ACLR successfully returned to play at least half a season. They also tended to retire sooner and to have fewer appearances and a decreased number of solo tackles."
This article is essentially useless in proving anything. It is talking about different techniques, neither of which you or I know Fano went through.
One again my friend, please keep thinking that 3 ACL tears is meaningless. I've provided a study, you've provided a study, and we've seen first hand evidence in Keenan Pili that support my claim. Outliers exist and I would gladly see Logan Fano come back and due well (outside of playing well in any BYU game), but statistically speaking that isn't likely to happen.
- Bio page
- TheLoneCougar
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2015
- Last login
- Jun 14, 2024
- Total posts
- 21,832 (4,319 FO)
Messages
Time
Apr 5, 5:37am
Apr 5, 6:33am
Apr 5, 3:36pm
Apr 5, 6:31am
Apr 5, 7:30am
Apr 5, 7:49am
Apr 5, 10:48am
Apr 5, 8:26am
Apr 5, 11:19am
Apr 5, 6:03am
Apr 5, 6:35am
Apr 5, 8:25am
Apr 6, 11:29am
Apr 6, 11:52am
Apr 5, 7:21am
Apr 5, 11:15am
Apr 5, 8:04am
Apr 5, 8:38am
Apr 5, 11:52am
Apr 5, 1:31pm
Apr 5, 2:26pm
Played in only 5 games total with his third ACL injury...yeah, star in the making material right there.
Apr 5, 4:55pm
Apr 5, 5:11pm
Apr 5, 10:03am
Apr 5, 10:13am
Apr 5, 11:03am
Apr 5, 11:17am
Apr 5, 11:05am
Apr 5, 3:44pm
Apr 6, 4:59pm