teh number of drives and scores that occur IN spite of the play called, because that play wasn't working as designed so Taysom creates ALL on his lonesome..then we have nothing to discuss.

This isn;t a Detmer esque offense where the QB makes plays WITHIN the offense... it is RILEY ball where teh QB is making plays OUTSIDE of the offense. PeeWee Pop Warner ball. Could Walsh succeed in an Anae offense? withot NFL talent all around him?

IF you can;t see teh difference between Walsh succeeding within an offense and Tasyom without one....again we have nothing to discuss.

If you gave Anae Walsh, my belief is that BYU would be TERRIBLE. I understand Anae would try to change the offense to suit Walsh,but without NFL talent everywhere. Our offense would look terrible. Just my belief. Nothing to go by but data we have. The Riley Heaps, Larson, NFL QB kicked to SUU, years and Taysoms running in spite of the offense to go on.