Anyone following "The Serial" podcast? If so, do you think Adnan is guilty?

Nov 13, 2014
5:15:33pm

Jeff Spicoli

Innocent? If Adnan didn't do it then do you think Jay did it?

I don't know if Adnan is guilty or not but either way I can't believe he was convicted on such shoddy evidence.

Report problem with this ad

Jeff Spicoli

Bio page: Jeff Spicoli
Joined: Feb 13, 2004
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 35,530 (198 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Anyone following "The Serial" podcast? If so, do you think Adnan is guilty?

Jeff Spicoli

11/13/14 5:15pm

I've been meaning to post a poll about this.

AndyDwyer

11/13/14 5:20pm

I haven't listened to the latest yet, but Yes, I think he did it.

Memmo

11/13/14 5:25pm

Why?

AndyDwyer

11/13/14 5:27pm

I just finished episode 6. Great podcast.

Cougar-Duck

11/13/14 5:27pm

Yes, but

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:28pm

Especially since Jay's story was not consistent.

AndyDwyer

11/13/14 5:31pm

But if Jay is lying, how lucky would he have to be that Adnan had nothing

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:32pm

It was more than just Jay's story. The cell phone records played a pretty

cracka

11/13/14 6:00pm

Generally corroborated, but also contradicted.

AndyDwyer

11/13/14 6:02pm

Well yeah. There were several contradictions in Jay's story.

cracka

11/13/14 6:08pm

But both Adnan and Jay said Jay had Adnans phone

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 6:03pm

Not true. That's why the narrator chick says the most damning

cracka

11/13/14 6:08pm

the cell records put the phone near the school until 4pm

The Shazad

11/13/14 7:07pm

Yeah, they established that the timeline to go to that other park

cracka

11/13/14 7:16pm

I think Jay did it with adnons knowledge.

johnnycarson

11/13/14 5:30pm

Why doesn't Adnan say that then?

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:31pm

Yeah I don't know. Maybe a threat?

johnnycarson

11/13/14 5:32pm

My friend has a theory that Jay did it and his girlfriend Stephanie helped him

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:34pm

What's so weird is that adnan seems to have the wrong reactions.

johnnycarson

11/13/14 5:36pm

It could be he's just given up hope. He's resigned to his fate?

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:37pm

What would their motive be? It's easier to come up w/ motive for Adnand.

B-town_coug

11/13/14 5:36pm

Jay could have been high on something and did it on accident. Regardless

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 5:39pm

I agree there probably wasn't enough evidence to convict Adnand...

B-town_coug

11/13/14 6:24pm

Agreed

TrueAndBlue

11/13/14 6:35pm

Today's episode pushes me more toward guilty

The Shazad

11/13/14 5:43pm

I just listened to today's, and I agree with you now.

AndyDwyer

11/13/14 10:45pm

I think Adnan's defense lawyer may have pushed me to vote guilty as well

The Shazad

11/14/14 6:30am

just listened to first episode last week. interesting stuff!

immacougar

11/13/14 5:46pm

I was on the fence until today's episode. Now I say guilty.

cracka

11/13/14 6:10pm

So is there supposed to be a resolution? Or are we all just gonna

johnnycarson

11/13/14 8:04pm

I've wondered the same thing. I feel like its starting to get a bit stale.

Posting on CougarBoard