but in reality we would've gone 4-4 at worst.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 23, 2014
3:18:55pm

dYrtbYkerYder

Report problem with this ad

dYrtbYkerYder

Bio page: dYrtbYkerYder
Joined: Sep 27, 2006
Last login: Apr 26, 2024
Total posts: 22,820 (136 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU and the MWC

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:16pm

Yes, because if we were in the MWC we would only play four games each season

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 3:18pm

Huh?

hxmCougar2000

11/23/14 3:18pm

but in reality we would've gone 4-4 at worst.

dYrtbYkerYder

11/23/14 3:18pm

Only other MWC team that would be a likely win for BYU is New Mexico

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:24pm

New Mexico = definite win. Likely wins are Wyo, SJSU, Hawaii. AFA and FSU

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:26pm

AFA demolished Boise State

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:39pm

Transitive property rarely works in football. Bronco has owned AFA for most

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:41pm

BYU last played AFA in 2010 and lost

AxelDC

11/23/14 7:53pm

Demolished? BSU lost due to 7 turnovers. Period. They outgained AFA by 130, had

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:46pm

Only in the minds of BYU fans does more 1st downs or more yards mean you won

Jonnyj

11/23/14 8:29pm

logic fail

crazY

11/23/14 3:19pm

But we would be in 1st in the Big 12 and tied for 1st in the ACC!!!!

Devbo

11/23/14 3:24pm

I like your logic.

PolarisPrime

11/23/14 5:26pm

With logic like that, you must have gone to one of those MWC schools.

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 3:25pm

Logic says BYU has declined significantly since leaving the MWC

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:28pm

Nevermind, misread your post

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 3:28pm

Stick to the numbers

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:30pm

Right, because back when we were in the MWC we only played four games

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 3:36pm

Nope, Air Force, Colo St. and othere are likely losses

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:39pm

No way we would lose to Wyoming and New Mexico

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 3:51pm

Since going independent, BYU even loss to sad San Jose State

Jonnyj

11/23/14 4:00pm

"Sad San Jose State"?? The team that was 11-2, and ranked that year?

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 4:09pm

It's sad to lose to SJSU no matter what

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:12pm

You are reaching.

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:28pm

So you are saying BYU would have lost four more games had we played the other

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 3:41pm

After losing to Nevada, logic says BYU could lose to any MWC team

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:43pm

You are either a Dairy yewt fan or a Suck Dogg State fan.

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 3:50pm

The evidence implies BYU may not be good enough for the MWC any more

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:52pm

So are you a Dairy Yewt or an Aztec yewt?

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 3:55pm

It's time BYU fans admit they aren't very good at football

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:59pm

What "fans" are good at football?

BYUFam1

11/23/14 4:37pm

Well to be honest, I am pretty good

thecelloguy

11/23/14 6:00pm

We had one down year against the MWC. BYU will be back. The MWC will continue

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 4:06pm

1-3 is an incomplete statement, kind of like giving out final grades at midterms

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 3:56pm

Unknowable. But thanks for that.

Iman23

11/23/14 3:41pm

Utah is about 3 plays away from being 1-7 this year. I'm glad you joined CB

Iman23

11/23/14 3:44pm

Please stick to BYU's record

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:50pm

Utah is awesome...if you thought high school was awesome. And gymnastics.

Iman23

11/23/14 3:53pm

But they won

AxelDC

11/23/14 6:58pm

By obvious trolls logic, we would have gone undefeated in the Mountain Worst

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 3:53pm

That's the whole point, BYU is on a steady decline

Jonnyj

11/23/14 3:57pm

You may not know this, but 2013, the year we didn't lose a single game to a

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 4:00pm

BYU is 10-6 against MWC teams since going independent

BeardedSpock

11/23/14 4:03pm

Before this really bad year, we were 9-3 against them. If we hadn't given the

CougDogg-e-Dogg

11/23/14 4:17pm

And the injuries to key guys likely had nothing to do with the decline either

CougarBacker

11/23/14 4:43pm

I don't think Utah has ever beat BSU....😀

BYU4eVeR

11/23/14 4:48pm

This thread is about the MWC, but BYU fans can't think of anything else but UU

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:20pm

Welcome back to the board Andy.

PolarisPrime

11/23/14 5:28pm

RE: BYU and the MWC

utah49er

11/23/14 5:40pm

You do realize that no one outside the wasatch thinks those are quality opponent

Iman23

11/23/14 6:14pm

I thought it was a joke as soon as I got to:

crazY

11/23/14 7:02pm

RE: You do realize that no one outside the wasatch thinks those are quality

utah49er

11/23/14 7:17pm

RE: You do realize that no one outside the wasatch thinks those are quality

utah49er

11/23/14 7:22pm

adorable. you think BSU is relevant.

crazY

11/24/14 9:13am

RE: BYU and the MWC

schofim

11/23/14 6:28pm

You need to extrapolate out. I get 6-6

AxelDC

11/23/14 6:57pm

What's funny is Crowton had a better MWC record the year he was fired. 5-3

byutx

11/23/14 6:57pm

So we lost to 2 of their 3 best teams and a middle team.

Blugar

11/23/14 7:24pm

Which puts BYU at the bottom

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:25pm

Poor logic.

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:28pm

When you lose to the top and the middle, there's only one place left to go

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:38pm

That is not logic you are using. It's called extrapolation. See below for an

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:39pm

BYU's current RPI is 53. CSU = 21, BSU = 24, USU = 38.

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:39pm

1-3 is only number that means didly squat

Jonnyj

11/23/14 7:43pm

Then keep it at 1-3 and quit extrapolating.

NewMexiCoug

11/23/14 7:44pm

And BYU's Schedule

Posting on CougarBoard