These are just the most common:
Player 1 wins rebounding.
Player 1 wins passing.
Player 1 wins ball handling.
Player 1 wins defense.
Player 1 loses on shooting, but while not a "shooter" is still a scorer.

Player 2 loses boards
Player 2 loses passing.
Loses ball handling.
Loses defense.
Wins shooting.

While we're talking about valid arguments, make a valid argument that supports one single aspect of the game over all of the other aspects combined.

Just saying, cases have been made over and over in favor of one. So far for the other, "take away shooting" is the argument.