Scout and Rivals have their recruiting rankings going back to 2002. I decided take each season from 2006 to present and see where BYU stands compared to their opponents strictly by looking at 5 year relative recruiting ranking averages. For example, BYU's overall average recruiting rating from 2002-2006 on Scout.com was 52. On Rivals during the same time period it was 68. Therefore their average recruiting rating for the 2006 schedule was 60. I went through BYU's and all their opponents' 5 year recruiting ranking from the 2006 season to present. Here are the results:

2006- BYU average recruiting ranking 60

@Arizona 32 L
N Oregon 34 W
@ BC 44 L
@ TCU 68 W
SDSU 68 W
@Utah 74 W
@CSU 78 W
Tulsa 82 W
UNLV 82 W
NM 91 W
USU 92 W
Wyo 96 W
@AF 110 W

2007- BYU average recruiting ranking 62

@UCLA 31 L
N UCLA 31 W
Arizona 36 W
@SDSU 67 W
TCU 70 W
Utah 71 W
CSU 84 W
@ UNLV 84 W
@Tulsa 86 L
@NM 91 W
@Wyo 97 W
AF 109 W
Eastern Washington NA W

2008- BYU average recruiting ranking 59

UCLA 25 W
@ Washington 36 W
N Arizona 36 L
@Utah 65 L
SDSU 74 W
@TCU 77 L
@CSU 88 W
UNLV 90 W
NM 95 W
Wyo 96 W
@Utah St. 99 W
@AF 106 W
Northern Iowa NA W

2009- BYU average recruiting ranking 56

N Oklahoma 11 W
FSU 12 L
N Oregon St. 48 W
Utah 61 W
TCU 72 L
@SDSU 83 W
@UNLV 87 W
@NM 93 W
@Wyoming 94 W
CSU 95 W
@Tulane 96 W
USU 105 W
AF 108 W

2010- BYU recruiting average ranking 51

@FSU 13 L
Washington 35 W
@Utah 56 L
@TCU 71 L
SDSU 85 W
UNLV 90 W
@CSU 90 W
N UTEP 92 W
NM 93 W
Nevada 96 L
Wyo 97 W
@AF 104 L
@USU 107 L

2011- BYU recruiting average ranking 52

@Texas 6 L
@Miss 24 W
@Oregon St. 51 W
Utah 52 L
UCF 57 W
N TCU 63 L
@Hawaii 79 W
N Tulsa 80 W
SJSU 101 W
Idaho 102 W
USU 103 W
NMSU 108 W
Idaho St. NA W

2012- BYU recruiting average ranking 54

@ND 14 L
@Utah 45 L
@GT 45 W
Oregon St. 51 L
Washington St. 67 W
@BSU 69 L
Hawaii 83 W
@SDSU 85 W
@SJSU 100 L
Idaho 104 W
USU 106 W
@NMSU 108 W
Weber St. NA W

2013- BYU average recruiting ranking 54

Texas 8 W
@ND 14 L
N Washington 30 L
@Virginia 39 L
Utah 42 L
@Wisconsin 51 L
GT 52 W
@Houston 59 W
BSU 65 W
Nevada 100 W
MTSU 102 W
@Utah State 106 W
Idaho St. NA W

2014- BYU average recruiting ranking 58

@Texas 10 W
@Cal 28 W
Virginia 41 W
Houston 63 W
@BSU 64 L
@UCF 72 L
N Memphis 79 L
@UConn 85 W
Nevada 95 L
@MTSU 98 W
UNLV 104 W
USU 105 L
Savannah St. NA W

Overall record 84-33
Overall record vs. inferior talent: 59-14
Overall record vs. similar talent (+/- 10 in the rankings): 13-7
Overall record vs. superior talent: 13-12