donnerstag, I do agree with you.

I have learned much from the constructive criticism that has been on this site. I am told that the coaches, the AD or their informers never know what is said on this and other sites regarding BYU football and what the fan base is saying, but I do see a direct correlation between what some of the fan base is saying and changes that are taking place in the program. So far, I see all the changes as positive changes and I praise the AD and the HC for those changes.

On the other hand, I do see a couple posters from time to time, that only want to be negative and find fault with what other posters are saying, but don’t seem to make any positive contribution of their own to the discussions.

Summary: I believe that if something comes across as a bit negative, but is used as constructive criticism, that might help steer our team in a positive direction, than that may be a good thing.

On the other hand, if the criticism and negativity is just to be argumentative with nothing intelligent to offer in the form of useful constructive criticism, that person should be asked to to not participate as it puts bad energy into the positive things that we are trying to accomplish.